An invasion without invaders

Across Europe, conservatives are wrong when they stoke fears of an Islamic invasion.

    As the mainstream has warmed to the refugees and their plight, the right has become more panicky and shrill, writes Diab [AFP]
    As the mainstream has warmed to the refugees and their plight, the right has become more panicky and shrill, writes Diab [AFP]

    It has been wondrous to behold the massive outpouring of sympathy towards refugees in Europe. Every "refugees welcome" placard and act of solidarity has restored my faith a little in our human ability to do collective good.

    But it strikes me that, as the mainstream has warmed to the refugees and their plight, the right has become more panicky and shrill, triggering the kind of fear and anxiety usually expressed by the defenceless towards ruthless conquerors.

    Bedraggled, desperate and unarmed, the stream of refugees flowing into Europe can only be referred to as an army in the loosest, most figurative sense of the word. Yet, across Europe, conservatives have been singing, in chorus, the refrain "Islamic invasion".

    Hungary's 'militarised strategy' in dealing with refugees

    "They're not refugees. This is an invasion," said Laszlo Kiss-Rigo, a bishop in southern Hungary, a country which has become a far-right hotbed in recent years and, stuck on a major transit route, has been building a wall to keep the refugees out.

    Calls to man the barricades

    What is most remarkable is that Bishop Kiss-Rigo's comments were a rebuke of his spiritual boss, Pope Francis' commendable appeal to European churches to take in refugees.

    Much further west, similar calls to man the barricades could also be heard.

    "It's an invasion that threatens our prosperity, our security, our culture and identity," said Dutch far-right firebrand Geert Wilders, who once infamously called for the banning of the Quran.

    Also read: One billionaire's dream to build a refugee utopia

    When it comes to prosperity, the influx of refugees (equivalent to just 0.37 percent of the EU's population since 2012) poses little to no threat, economists and other experts agree. An analysis by the Brookings Institute reveals that the inflow of refugees actually has a net positive effect on host economies - and the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) agrees.

    If the European economy stands to benefit from the influx of refugees, why all the panic?


    If the European economy stands to benefit from the influx of refugees, why all the panic?

    One reason is economic anxiety. Across Europe, job insecurity has risen dramatically while youth unemployment in many countries is perilously high. In addition, the corrosion of the welfare state and severe austerity measures have left millions reeling in shock.

    Rather than attribute Europe's economic ills on the continent's growing welfare state for the wealthy, the corporations exporting (or "outsourcing") jobs for greater profit and financial sector mismanagement, far-right demagogues find it easier to blame the weak and kick those who are already down.

    In addition, the periphery countries dealing with the brunt of the crisis are the poorest and least-equipped to do so.

    Potential danger

    Beyond economics, many Europeans are genuinely concerned about the potential danger to their security posed by refugees. While it seems far-fetched and even preposterous to people like me that those fleeing the combined terror of the Assad regime and ISIL will themselves turn to terrorism, many ordinary Europeans do not possess the luxury of that insight.

    Also read: Why Al Jazeera will not say Mediterranean 'migrants'

    In addition, there is the slim chance that ISIL will play on these fears and send a handful of terrorists amid the flow of genuine refugees. In such an instance, all it takes is a single act of calculated terror to cause Fortress Europe to pull up the drawbridges it has recently slightly let down.

    Migrants and refugees walk towards a registration camp after crossing the Macedonian-Greek border [AFP]

    However, fears about security are subordinate to anxieties about culture and identity. Since World War II, Western Europe has witnessed a remarkable demographic transformation in which citizens from former colonies - and from Turkey, in the case of Germany - and their offspring now constitute a significant minority of the population.

    Though many have related to this new multicultural reality as enriching and empowering, others have found it troublesome and threatening, particularly those who feel their culture is superior to those of the immigrants.

    When coupled with the corrosive effects of globalisation and rapid technological development, as well as the rapid demise of religion in many parts of Europe in recent decades, many feel adrift in an uncharted ocean.

    Although fanatics capture the headlines and people's imaginations, this death of religion has also been occurring among what Europe identifies as its Muslim minority, which was never defined so monolithically in the past. For example, according to some studies, more than a fifth of "Muslims" in France don't believe in Islam nor practise it.

    One reason why anxiety towards Muslims carries an extra punch compared to other groups ... is the centuries-old mutual rivalry between neighbouring Islam and Christendom.


    Mutual rivalry

    One reason why anxiety towards Muslims carries an extra punch compared to other groups, such as Indians and Chinese, is the centuries-old mutual rivalry between neighbouring Islam and Christendom (nowadays, referred to as the "West").

    Populists and demagogues have been riding, and fanning, the wave of re-Christianisation and growing Islamophobia by playing the history card relentlessly.

    "When it comes to living together with Muslim communities, we are the only ones who have experience because we had the possibility to go through that experience for 150 years," said Viktor Orban, Hungary's far-right "Viktator", evoking memories of the Ottoman carve-up of the medieval Kingdom of Hungary, which empowered the peasantry but destroyed the ruling class.

    This is a far cry from the earlier pronouncements by Orban, who is an atheist who now regularly talks about "Christian values", that "Turkey is not a state at the edge of Europe any more".

    What Orban's swinging rhetorical pendulum underlines is that there is no "clash of civilisations", just clashes of interests and convenience.

    Moreover, any sensible observer should be able to see clearly that the refugees of today are not the invaders of history. In our interconnected world, people need to conquer their fears and let sensibility and humanity reign.

    Khaled Diab is an award-winning Egyptian-Belgian journalist, writer and blogger. He is the author of Intimate Enemies: Living with Israelis and Palestinians in the Holy Land. He blogs at

    The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera's editorial policy.

    SOURCE: Al Jazeera



    Meet the deported nurse aiding asylum seekers at US-Mexico border

    Meet the deported nurse helping refugees at the border

    Francisco 'Panchito' Olachea drives a beat-up ambulance around Nogales, taking care of those trying to get to the US.

    The rise of Pakistan's 'burger' generation

    The rise of Pakistan's 'burger' generation

    How a homegrown burger joint pioneered a food revolution and decades later gave a young, politicised class its identity.

    'We will cut your throats': The anatomy of Greece's lynch mobs

    The brutality of Greece's racist lynch mobs

    With anti-migrant violence hitting a fever pitch, victims ask why Greek authorities have carried out so few arrests.