Vatican judges reject butler trial evidence

Pope Benedict XVI’s former butler Paolo Gabriele has gone on trial, accused of leaking confidential Vatican memos that revealed cloak-and-dagger politics among the pontiff’s closest aides.

Gabriele sat quietly on Saturday for the start of a closely-watched case which could see him receive up to four years in prison for aggravated theft if convicted.

In its first hearing of the case, the three-judge Vatican tribunal threw out some evidence gathered during the investigation.

The trial was adjourned until Tuesday, but the judge told the court in the city-state that he hoped to finish the hearing by the end of next week.

Gabriele said he grew disgusted by the “evil and corruption” he witnessed. He told investigators he was acting as an “agent” of the Holy Spirit to help the pope put the Roman Catholic Church back on track.

Using the codename “Maria”, he is accused of meeting Gianluigi Nuzzi, an investigative reporter, earlier this year and passing him copies of secret papers.

Al Jazeera’s Jonah Hull reports from the Vatican

The trial will unfold in a nineteenth-century courtroom behind the apse of St Peter’s basilica in a corner of the city state that is strictly off-limits to the millions of visitors who visit the Vatican every year. If convicted, however, Gabriele will be sent to an Italian prison.

Television cameras are banned and only 10 journalists are allowed to attend.

The Vatican has said the 85-year-old German pope is deeply hurt by the betrayal of confidence by someone he “knew, loved and respected”.

Gabriele has confessed and has written a letter begging the pope for forgiveness.

Many commentators have said they expect the pope to pardon Gabriele. Many also question whether he really acted alone or as part of a wider group of disgruntled Vatican employees who could even include high-placed prelates.

Al Jazeera’s Jonah Hull, reporting from Vatican City, said the pope himself plays a unique role in this case as both “victim and supreme judge”.

Our correspondent said though Vatican watchers think a pardon is likely, Gabriele will first have to be tried before he can be pardoned.

An investigation into the “Vatileaks” scandal is ongoing.

Life service

Gabriele has spent his entire adult life as a Vatican servant, starting out as a cleaner at the Secretariat of State – the main administrative body of the Catholic Church – and becoming butler to the pope in 2006.

He served the pope his meals and clothed him and is a constant presence in official photographs, adjusting the pope’s cloak, holding his umbrella or riding with him in the “popemobile” through crowds on foreign trips.

The leaked correspondence offers an extraordinary glimpse into the inner workings of the Holy See. It includes letters from a former head of the Vatican governorate alleging he was forced out of his post for tackling widespread fraud.

” There is a lot of hypocrisy, this is the kingdom of hypocrisy … Being a witness to truth means being ready to pay the price. ” – Paolo Gabriele, former butler to Pope Benedict XVI

The scandal has been an embarrassment for the Vatican, though more for the apparent ease with which sensitive papers clearly intended to be read only by the pope and a few confidantes could be leaked, than for their content.

The impact of Gabriele’s trial and the scandal overall, said Al Jazeera’s Jonah Hull, will be in “the light that it will shine for the Italian media … the Italian people … and Catholics at-large for the inner workings of this mysterious place”.

Vatican gendarmes arrested Gabriele on May 23 and raided his home behind the Vatican walls, finding copies of confidential documents and gifts intended for the pope including a gold nugget and a 100,000-euro cheque.

Gabriele, one of only 594 citizens of the Vatican, was well known and generally liked in the tight-knit community that inhabitants the historic city, but there were also voices of criticism cited in court documents.

“He was very closed,” one of the pope’s four housekeepers was quoted as saying.

“He always seemed to be competitive and seeking approval for his behaviour. He was judgemental in daily life,” she said.

‘Dirty laundry’

Vatican police also ordered psychological examinations of Gabriele during his 53 days in custody, which concluded he was “an impressionable subject able to commit a variety of actions that can damage himself and/or others”.

The only recorded interview that Gabriele has given was in February with Gianluigi Nuzzi, the investigative journalist who published the leaks.

Gabriele spoke in the darkness, his voice muffled and his identity hidden.

The butler expressed frustration with a culture of secrecy in the Vatican – from the mysterious disappearance of the daughter of a Vatican employee in 1983 to a quickly hushed-up double murder and suicide by a Swiss guard in 1998.

“There is a kind of omerta against the truth, not so much because of a power struggle but because of fear, because of caution,” Gabriele said in the interview, using the term for the code of silence of the Sicilian mafia.

He told Nuzzi there were “around 20” like-minded people in the Vatican.

“It annoys people when you stick your nose in their dirty laundry,” he said, adding that the leaking of documents was “a gesture of rage” against inaction.

“There is a lot of hypocrisy, this is the kingdom of hypocrisy,” he said.

Gabriele said he was aware of the consequences of his actions but said the potential to change something in the Vatican was worth the risk.

“Being a witness to truth means being ready to pay the price,” he said.

Gabriele is being tried together with Claudio Sciarpelletti, a computer technician at the Vatican who is accused of abetting his crime.