[QODLink]
Danny Schechter
Danny Schechter
News Dissector Danny Schechter edits Mediachannel1.org. He is the author of The Crime of Our Time.
Hu's on next: US-China roadshow
Can Sino-American relations be restored? What will be the impact on the economy and security if they fail to reconcile?
Last Modified: 19 Jan 2011 14:11
Chinese President Hu Jintao arrives in the US for a visit being billed as the most important US-China summit since Deng Xiaoping's visit to Washington 30 years ago [Getty]

On the eve of the Chinese President's visit to the US, there is intense speculation about his intentions - and ours. I recently found myself in a dark room at the Anthology Film Archive in New York's East Village, watching a spectacular documentary by Chinese filmmaker Zhao Liang called Petition.

It's about the tens of thousands of Chinese citizens with grievances, who seek redress at offices ostensibly set up to resolve their problems.

The right to petition is guaranteed by the Chinese constitution. Yes, China has a constitution, but it is unevenly enforced - like our own. Falun Gong first tried, but failed, to bring its human rights claims to a petition office like the bureaucratic centres shown in the film. A small army of individuals every day, bravely - sometimes fanatically -  insists it is their human right to be heard. In Falun Gong's case, they were outlawed and systematically repressed at a large human cost.

Issue of hypocrisy

The teaser synopsis for Petition states: "Since 1996, Zhao has documented the 'petitioners' who come from all over China to make complaints in Beijing about abuses committed by their local authorities. Gathered near the complaint offices, living in most cases in makeshift shelters, the complainants wait for months or years to obtain justice. Peasants thrown off their land, workers from factories which have gone into liquidation, small homeowners who have seen their houses demolished but received no compensation, they pursue justice with unceasing stubbornness, facing the most brutal intimidation and most often finding that their hopes are in vain."

Before you put this down just to highlight authoritarianism and insensitivity in China, remember the song "before you excuse me, take a look at yourself".

Think of all the Americans who get nowhere fighting their City Halls or battling denials of claims by health insurance companies or foreclosures by banks. Think of the vast growth in poverty and the persistence of high unemployment. Think of the millions of Americans behind bars. We have no petition office, which I am sure must resolve some issues - even if the film didn't show many.

Our systems may be different, but some of the top-down ways our rulers operate are similar. Now, our two governments are about to sit down with each other to discuss common problems and stubborn differences.

Nemesis no more

"The US-China summit this week could rank among the most pivotal in history," writes Leslie Gelb, who went from the New York Times to the Council on Foreign Relations to the appropriately named Daily Beast.

"Presidents Barack Obama and Hu Jintao can either find fresh ways to work out increasing differences, or they can settle for friendly gasbag rhetoric that will bow to their mutual and mounting hawkish pressures. But failure to compromise on tough economic and security issues will have dangerous consequences for both leaders."

Elite journalists tend to worry more about the tenure of elites than the well-being of the people. Yet, when you think about US-China relations, it's not only just governments that are wrestling over policy.

For example, whenever Washington summons up the courage to criticize China's dismal and repressive human rights record, Beijing fires back with the scorecard of US police abuses and mass incarceration claims. They report regularly on Obama's backpedaling on US human rights.

The summit is being carefully stage-managed by lower-level officials on both sides who have already come up with some compromises that each side can use to show how flexible and responsive they are. Each side must save face after all.

China's growing power

In case you haven't noticed, the world has changed with China's economy growing faster and doing better - at least for now - than ours.

Money represents real power in this world, and our currency seems to be declining while theirs is in the ascendancy.

China's President Hu Jintao is sending contradictory signals. In one conciliatory statement, he called for the US and China to work out their mutual problems. He sounded reasonable and friendly.

"There is no denying that there are some differences and sensitive issues between us," Hu told American newspapers. "We both stand to gain from a sound China-US relationship, and lose from confrontation.''

At the same time, the Chinese are scaring Wall Street and its cadre of DC henchmen by questioning the future of the dollar as the world's reserve currency. Even as China's investments in America's bonds and other financial instruments has become essential for our well being and China's as well, there are many in Beijing who don't like the dependence on an American system that has lost them money and independence.

All countries have their own interests, although the US likes to pretend that everything we want is in the world's interest. Our PR may be better, but our global image is severely tarnished by our wars and by WikiLeaks disclosures.

The US has been pressing the Chinese to let its currency appreciate for years. The Chinese often sound as if they will, but, in the end, they haven't because doing so would hurt their economy and spark more unemployment.

US Congressional pressure

Now Congress is getting into the act to add pressure on Beijing. AP reports, "Three US senators announced plans Monday to renew their effort to penalize China for what they term currency "manipulation," on the eve of a state visit by Chinese President Hu Jintao.

"Our message to President Hu is, 'Welcome to America, but we want to make sure we have a fair trading system'," said Michigan Senator Debbie Stabenow, who joined fellow Democrats Charles Schumer and Bob Casey in the announcement.

The bill to be introduced in the new Congress would "vigorously address currency misalignments that unfairly and negatively impact US trade," the three said in a joint statement.

China will not be swayed by this pressure move. They don't like being bullied and have their own grievances with our economic polices, including US cases filed against China at the World Trade Organisation that they view as invalid and protectionist political moves.

China is aware of how to "win friends" in the US, as Reuters reports:

"The Chinese government kicked off a four-day US trade mission on Monday by signing six deals in Houston, with undisclosed US companies worth $600m, according to Chinese state media reports.

"The deals came a day before Chinese President Hu Jintao arrives in the United States for a visit being billed as the most important US-China summit since Deng Xiaoping's visit to Washington 30 years ago."

The future of our relations is not just dependent on what the leaders say or agree on at summits. China is wary of US military power encircling them. They are being forced to spend more money than they want to on naval ships and stealth planes. This is a country that grew up with Mao's dictum that "political power grows out of the barrel of a gun".

The future of US-China relations

As the Telegraph noted recently, "on virtually all the main issues that separate the two nations, [China] seems intransigent and uncompromising. The sense of threat is heightened by the fact that, while America is gripped by economic, social and political self-doubt, the Chinese have never been more certain of their ascendancy."

It may be that both countries are shakier than we think. There may be no economic recovery in the United States for five years while some hedge funds fear that "China is a bubble close to bursting". Another article in the Telegraph reports, "The world is looking to China as a springboard out of recession - but some hedge funds are betting the country's credit and growth levels cannot be sustained."

So far, neither Washington nor Beijing has realized the apocalyptic projections of their many critics. Both states at least pay lip service to their ideals.

The US says it wants more democracy in China, but its officials like Tim Geithner are upset by the debates taking place there, and pine for the days when they could deal with a dictator like Mao or Deng who, as the New York Times explained, "commanded basically unquestioned authority … Our leaders prefer dealing with that type of authority and wish they had it here."

Back in Beijing, in the shabby Petition Villages where Chinese citizens soldier on in their fight for justice - or in the US, where citizens are frustrated and angry with an economic crisis that appears to have no end - no one will expect much from this summit in faraway Washington, where diplomatic dances produce just smiles.

Danny Schechter edits Mediachannel.org. He directed Plunder - The Crime of Our Time, a film on DVD about the financial crisis.

The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera's editorial policy. 

Source:
Al Jazeera
Topics in this article
People
Country
City
Organisation
Featured on Al Jazeera
Swathes of the British electorate continue to show discontent with all things European, including immigration.
Astronomers have captured images of primordial galaxies that helped light up the cosmos after the Big Bang.
Critics assail British photographer's portrayal of indigenous people, but he says he's highlighting their plight.
As Western stars re-release 1980s charity hit, many Africans say it's a demeaning relic that can do more harm than good.
Featured
Remnants of deadly demonstrations to be displayed in a new museum, a year after protests pushed president out of power.
No one convicted after 58 people gunned down in cold blood in 2009 in the country's worst political mass killing.
While hosting the World Internet Conference, China tries Tiananmen activist for leaking 'state secrets' to US website.
Once staunchly anti-immigrant, some observers say the conservative US state could lead the way in documenting migrants.
NGOs say women without formal documentation are being imprisoned after giving birth in Malaysia.