Australia says China’s actions at odds with rhetoric of peace

The defence minister says there is a ‘significant disconnect’ between what China says and what it does.

Australia's defence minister was speaking after Canberra said it had tracked a ship from the People's Liberation Army Navy inside its EEZ [File: Bobby Yip/Reuters]

China’s “alarming” actions do not match its rhetoric about promoting peace and prosperity in the region, Australia’s defence minister said on Friday after a Chinese navy ship was tracked sailing through the country’s exclusive economic zone.

Defence Minister Peter Dutton listed China’s militarisation of the South China Sea, recent aggression towards Taiwan and the introduction of the national security law in Hong Kong as examples where China’s actions failed to match its rhetoric.

“We’re all familiar with the frequent claims of the Chinese government that it is committed to peace, cooperation and development,” Dutton said in a speech in Canberra.

“And yet we bear witness to a significant disconnect between the words and the actions. We’ve watched very closely as the Chinese government has engaged in increasingly alarming activities.”

The Chinese embassy in Canberra said Dutton had distorted China’s foreign policy, misled the Australian people and was “fanning conflict and division between peoples and nations”.

“It is inconceivable that China-Australia relationship will take on a good momentum … if the Australian government bases its national strategy on such visionless analysis and outdated mentality,” it said in a statement.

Relations between the two countries reached a nadir in 2020 when Canberra backed a United Nations inquiry into the origins of COVID-19, which first emerged in the Chinese city of Wuhan two years ago.

Dutton referred to China’s increasingly assertive claims in the South China Sea where it has blocked the Philippines within the Southeast Asian nation’s own EEZ [File: Jay Director/AFP]

China responded by cutting off ministerial contacts and imposing hefty tariffs on Australian exports of wine, barley, beef, coal and seafood, effectively nullifying a 2015 free trade agreement. Australia and its ally the United States branded the move “economic coercion”.

Dutton’s comments came as Australia confirmed it had monitored a Chinese intelligence ship sailing in August inside Australia’s exclusive economic zone (EEZ) but not in Australian territorial waters.

Prime Minister Scott Morrison said the ship – the second of its type monitored off the Australian coast in as many months – was travelling legally.

“But don’t think for a second that we weren’t keeping our eye on them, as they were seeking to keep an eye on us,” Morrison told reporters in Adelaide.

“What it demonstrates is now no one can be complacent about the situation in the Indo-Pacific.”

In September, a new security pact between Australia, the United States and the United Kingdom, dubbed AUKUS, was widely viewed as an attempt to shore up regional military muscle in the face of China’s growing presence. China has called AUKUS a danger to world peace.

China has also been flexing its muscles in the South China Sea, with its coastguard vessels this month firing water cannon at a Philippines supply ship within the Southeast Asian nation’s EEZ at Second Thomas Shoal and blocking access. It has also demanded the Philippines remove a military outpost there – claiming the shoal is its territory.

Manila has refused, noting that a 2016 ruling by a UN-backed court of arbitration rejected China’s claim to almost the entire sea under its controversial nine-dash line.

Source: Al Jazeera, Reuters