ECHR rejects case seeking to blame Vatican for abuse

European Court of Human Rights rules that the Holy See enjoys sovereign immunity in landmark case.

The Roman Catholic Church has been rocked by a series of sexual abuse scandals around the world, often involving children, in recent decades [File: Gregorio Borgia/AP]

The European Court of Human Rights has ruled that the Vatican cannot be sued in a local court for sexual abuse committed by Catholic priests, affirming that it enjoys sovereign immunity and that the misconduct of priests and their superiors cannot be attributed to the Holy See.

The ECHR dismissed a case on Tuesday brought by two dozen people who said they were victims of abusive priests in Belgium.

The 24 plaintiffs had argued the Holy See was liable because of the “structurally deficient” way the Catholic hierarchy had for decades covered up cases of priests who raped and molested children.

The plaintiffs appealed to the Strasbourg-based court after Belgian courts ruled they had no jurisdiction given the Holy See’s immunity as a sovereign state.

The ECHR said the Belgian judges were correct and that the victims had not been deprived of their right to have access to a court.

It restated the Belgian court ruling that the Holy See enjoys sovereign immunity and that no exception to that rule applied since the misconduct of bishops in handling abuse cases could not be attributed to the Vatican.

Citing the Belgian decision, the European rights court said the pope was not the “principal” of his bishops, “that the misconduct attributed directly to the Holy See hadn’t been committed on Belgian territory but in Rome; and that neither the pope nor the Holy See had been present on Belgian territory when the misconduct attributed to the leaders of the church in Belgium had been committed,” according to a summary of the ruling.

The ECHR said it was not appropriate to substitute its own assessment since the Belgian decision had not been arbitrary or unreasonable.

‘The church repeatedly evades justice’

Tuesday’s ruling, the first time the Holy See’s immunity was tested by the European court, was a Chamber judgement. Both sides have three months to ask that the case be heard by the court’s Grand Chamber for a final decision.

In a dissenting opinion, Judge Darian Pavli disputed the Belgian court’s finding about the level of authority that the pope exercises over his bishops. He argued that Belgian judges had not considered evidence that the pope does in fact hire and fire bishops and that the Vatican as a policy had imposed a code of silence over the handling of abuse cases worldwide.

As a result, Pavli argued, the European tribunal should have found that Belgian judges did indeed deprive the victims of access to a court.

The Holy See has successfully argued in US courts that the pope is not the boss of his bishops, blocking attempts by victims who have similarly tried to hold the Holy See and the pope liable for their abuse.

More such lawsuits have been filed in recent years, including from victims of ex-Cardinal Theodore McCarrick, who was defrocked by Pope Francis in 2019 after a Vatican investigation found he sexually abused minors and adults.

These lawsuits have cited a Vatican-commissioned report published last year that found a series of popes, Holy See officials and bishops downplayed or dismissed reports of his sexual misconduct as he rose through the church hierarchy.

The Vatican declined to comment on the ruling, saying it speaks for itself. The victims’ lawyers did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment.

Anne Barrett Doyle, co-founder of the online resource, said the ruling was a “galling reminder” of the Vatican’s impunity because of its status as a sovereign state.

“The church’s dual identity as a religion and a state allows it to shape-shift according to the threat it faces in courts,” she said in a statement.

“No other religious institution enjoys the same buffet of legal protections. The result is that the church repeatedly evades justice and its untold millions of victims are left to suffer.”

Source: AP