Russia’s LGBT victimised by ‘gay propaganda’ law

Legislation targeting ‘non-traditional sexual relations’ seen as yet another attempt to smother civil society.

A gay rights activist is detained by a police officer in Moscow during a pro-LGBT demonstration [Alexander Zemlianichenko/AP]

Russian drag artist Yulianna Prosvirnina was revelling in the success of the buzzing gay and lesbian party she had organised in Moscow when a hooded mob burst into the venue.

“They stopped the party and shouted, ‘Who wants to be first?'” the 26-year-old lesbian performer said.

“Then tables started flying, glasses were breaking everywhere, and girls were kicked in the stomach. Many people hid and most were so scared – too scared to stand together and defend one another,” Prosvirnina said.

Prosvirnina threw the ill-fated party, which saw the club trashed and four people hospitalised, just months after a law banning homosexual “propaganda” was passed in June 2013.

Activists say it has fuelled anti-gay abuse, discrimination and violence, spawned a “chilling effect”, and victimised young lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) people and deterred them from coming out and seeking support.

 Russian trolls spread government propaganda

The Russian legislation banned the spreading of “propaganda for non-traditional sexual relations” to minors and introduced fines for individuals and organisations that breach the law, which critics describe as arbitrary and hard to implement.

The law is seen by many as one in a series of moves by President Vladimir Putin to crack down on dissent, smother civil society, and draw closer to the Russian Orthodox Church, which has spoken out against homosexuality and is one of the most influential institutions in the country.

Stoking violence

Punishable by jail in the Soviet Union, homosexuality was decriminalised in 1993, yet much of the LGBT community remains underground, and prejudice runs deep.

The law has only been enforced in a handful of cases, and Elena Klimova – founder of one of Russia’s only online communities for LGBT youth, Deti-404, where users share stories of attacks and humiliation – was the latest person to be convicted in July and was fined 50,000 roubles ($830).

“We [LGBT people] are treated as subhuman, with no civil or human rights. We are social non-entities, and we are even considered diseased and dangerous to society,” said Prosvirnina, a self-titled drag king who goes by the stage name Iven Batler.

Tanya Cooper, a Russian researcher at Human Rights Watch, said the gay propaganda law was part of a wider crackdown on civil society and anybody who challenged traditional Russian values.

Since Putin returned to the presidency in May 2012, Russia has adopted laws tightening controls on nongovernmental organisations funded from abroad and barring those deemed to pose a threat to its constitutional order, defence, or security.

“Activists see the propaganda law as part of a broader crackdown to create a chilling effect and clamp down on those who speak out and have opposing opinions,” Cooper said.

“But LGBT people see the law as an assault on their identity and community, driven by violence and state-sponsored homophobia flowing from television screens, radio stations, newspapers and even celebrities,” she said.

RELATED: Russia says transsexuals unfit to drive

A vigilante group called Occupy Paedophilia has gained infamy for using Russian social media to connect with gay men and lure them into traps, attacking and humiliating them on camera then posting the videos online, where they are shared and “liked”.


In July, a video of two men being harassed, abused and threatened for walking hand-in-hand in Moscow went viral.

Another radical Orthodox group, God’s Will, seeks to identify pro-LGBT professionals, expose them, and campaign for their dismissal.

Cooper said she fears the law has not only fuelled, but also legitimised anti-LGBT sentiment and violence among the public.

She said victims who muster the courage to report such incidents to the police and reveal their sexuality are routinely dismissed – and even mocked – by the authorities, who refuse to take violence against the LGBT community seriously.

“Before the gay propaganda law, LGBT people would not have been openly attacked in broad daylight … but now they don’t feel safe on the streets or even talking to people online.”

“The government has portrayed the LGBT community as a hazard to children, while groups like Occupy Paedophilia conflate homosexuality with paedophilia… What kind of message does this send out to young LGBT people across Russia?” Cooper said.

Activists fear the law has left young LGBT people feeling isolated and neglected in a country with a child and teenage suicide rate three times that of the global average, according to a 2013 report by Russia’s state consumer rights agency.

 Russian gay rights bill seen as anti-gay campaign

Double discrimination

For LGBT youths living with HIV, the stigma surrounding their sexuality and illness means they face double discrimination and even greater anxiety, said Evgeny Pisemskiy, founder of Phoenix Plus, a Russian NGO for HIV-positive gay men.

He recalled the account of a gay 17-year-old Russian boy whose mother said she should “have got rid of him” before he was born after he was diagnosed with HIV.

“He saw a great counsellor for two months, who helped him and his mother to understand that life was not over… But as a minor today, he would not be able to receive that support under the gay propaganda law,” said Pisemskiy.

Although the law has led to a spike in violence and stifled much of Russia’s LGBT community, it has also brought together activists, campaigners and rights groups, according to Anastasia Smirnova, policy officer at LGBT network ILGA-Europe.

“There is more solidarity among civil society now than ever before … and LGBT rights are at the forefront of the human rights agenda. Who knows what change this might bring about?” she said.

A version of this story was originally published on the Thomson Reuters Foundation news service

Source: Reuters