South Africa extended their unbeaten run against England to 11 matches at Twickenham on Saturday as the Springboks held off the hosts 16-15 in their final rugby test of the year.
In rain and heavy underfoot conditions, ideally suited to the visitors’ big forwards, Pat Lambie and Toby Flood traded penalties in the opening half as South Africa took a slim advantage.
A fortuitous try soon after the restart for powerhouse flanker Willem Alberts gave the Springboks the momentum and while England looked threatening at times, South Africa just kept them at bay.
“It could’ve gone either way…..we were very fortunate…the 50-50s went for us,” Springboks coach Heyneke Meyer told reporters.
“I said to Jean (de Villiers) that six months ago this team would have lost this game so after a long season I’ll take one point on the day.”
England’s faint hopes of overtaking France to the No. 4 ranking to avoid being drawn with one of the top three southern hemisphere teams for the 2015 World Cup now appear over.
In the day’s other action, New Zealand smashed beleaguered Six Nations champions Wales 33-10. Australia also held off a second-half fightback from Italy to win 22-19 in Rome and preserve their perfect record against the Azzurri.
Also, France subdued Samoa 22-14, Ireland thrashed Argentina 46-24 and Tonga humbled Scotland 21-15.
England had talked all week about making an impression from the kick off and they rewarded coach Stuart Lancaster immediately, showing much more physical intent than a week ago when they lost to Australia.
A charge down from the first ruck of the game inside South Africa’s 22 was followed by a clever and incisive run from winger Mike Brown and the pressure eventually told on the Springboks as Flood landed his second penalty attempt.
While England made most of the early play, South Africa rolled up their sleeves and drew level primarily thanks to lock Eben Etzebeth’s spoiling tactics at the line out.
Flood and his South Africa opposite number Lambie were at it again in margins of three before the opening quarter was complete but it was England who looked the more threatening. Two missed penalties from Flood cost them what would have been a deserved half-time advantage.
A desire to front up to the Springboks’ monster pack created opportunities for England in the first 40 minutes, none better than to fullback Alex Goode who ran off the shoulder of scrumhalf Ben Youngs, slicing through the ruck and deep inside the visitors’ 22.
Whatever South Africa coach Heyneke Meyer said to his players at half time spurred them into life. A risky decision to turn down a very kickable penalty a minute after the restart in favour of a lineout proved to be inspired for captain Jean de Villiers.
In propelling himself forward, lock Juandre Kruger left the ball behind and England’s attempts to boot it clear failed.
Alberts was on hand to scoop up a Tom Wood knock-on from the rebound.
A melee inside England’s 22 sparked by Etzebeth followed the try but all was forgotten when centre Manu Tuilagi thwarted a threatening South African attack with a timely intercept. Again, England’s inability to turn possession and territory into points was telling.
Lancaster’s men attacked with passion and verve in the final quarter and while they closed to within striking distance, debate is sure to rage over England captain Chris Robshaw’s decision to kick at goal with less than two minutes remaining and his team trailing by four points.
While the kick was successful, it left England with little time to return to South Africa’s half and the Springboks shut down the game to close a long season in the best possible way.
The Springboks now head home after also beating Ireland and Scotland on their northern hemisphere tour while England host world champions New Zealand in seven days’ time.