Hitch holds up Turkey-Armenia deal

Turkish objections to Armenian statement delays signing of historic accords in Zurich.

    Protests have been held particularly by the Armenian disapora concerning the accords [AFP]

    'Unacceptable' language

    "There was a meeting earlier today between the Turkish delegation and Hillary Clinton. At that meeting everyone was given advance copies of what everyone else was going to say at the ceremony - the Turks at that point flagged up a problem with what the Armenians were going to say," Fisher said.

    "When you've had almost a hundred years of hatred, of animosity, of distrust, people are thinking that the delay of an hour or so isn't that much to bear"

    Alan Fisher, Al Jazeera's correspondent

    "The main problem, we think, was around the word 'genocide' and how it was going to be used. The Armenians were told that the Turks found their language unnacceptable and therefore they are staying in their hotel for the time being.

    "We have been told by the Swiss officials that this signing will still go ahead. But obviously when you've had almost a hundred years of hatred, of animosity, of distrust, people are thinking that the delay of an hour or so isn't that much to bear," he said.

    The planned signing is the culmination of more than a year of Swiss-mediated talks.

    The Swiss foreign ministry confirmed on Friday that Edward Nalbandian and Ahmet Davutoglu, the respective Armenian and Turkish foreign ministers, would take part in the ceremony.

    Sergei Lavrov, the Russian foreign minister, and Bernard Kouchner, the French foreign minster, are among those due to attend the signing of accords as a show of support.

    Nationalist opposition

    The protocols would still need ratification by their respective parliaments after being signed.

    That endorsement will have to come as nationalists on both sides protest the accords, particularly an Armenian diaspora which is demanding that Turkey acknowledge the killings of 1.5 million Armenians during World War I as genocide.

    Turkey has disputed the claims of genocide, with support from the US and UK, saying that the real death toll is lower.

    In depth

     Analysis: Armenians divided on Turkey accords
     Video: Thaw in Armenian-Turkish accords
     Video: Turkey-Armenia rift narrows
     Turkey-Armenia Protocols

    Many Turks see the fighting as a civil war caused by the collapse of the Ottoman Empire during which an unverifiable number of Turks also died - although both sides agree that more Armenians than Turks were killed.

    Both governments have majorities in parliament but are expected to hold back on immediately ratifying the protocols due to the opposition.

    Speaking to Al Jazeera, Styopa Safaryan, an Armenian MP for the opposition Heritage Party, said: "At the very beginning, we welcomed this process, hoping that it will bring together Armenian and Turkish sides to provide an open and honest conversation on contemporary and historic issues.

    "But after the disclosure of the signed protocols after August 31, we were surprised to see that non-directly, Turkish pre-conditions were on the table ... [Yet] there are no Armenian preconditions.

    "That is why yesterday we had a huge demonstration in Armenia. People marched to the memorial of the Armenian genocide. People said no to protocol."

    Powerful protocols

    Al Jazeera's Anita McNaught, reporting from Karakoyunlu on Turkey's border with Armenia, said: "These protocols are powerful, but they have no legally enforceable status.

    "They are reliant on the goodwill and moral authority of the parties who are the participants in it.

    "What happens next is ratification ... they've got to sell this to their people and the politicians.

    "If they push it though and they ratify it in parliament, we see two things: immediately, the establishment of diplomatic relations; then within two months the opening of borders."

    For now, however, the question of reconciliation remains contentious at the very least.

    As many as 10,000 people marched from Yerevan, the Armenian capital, to a hilltop memorial to World War I-era massacres on Friday to condemn the accords, some carrying placards reading "No Concessions to the Turks".

    The move is expected to help Ankara in its bid to join the EU, while Armenia may benefit from closer ties to the West and greater economic openness with Turkey.

    The issue of the disputed enclave of the Armenian-majority enclave of Nagorny-Karabakh also complicates the situation.

    Disputed enclave

    The enclave broke away from Azerbaijan after a war in the early 1990s, with Turkey closing its borders with Armenia in support of Azerbaijan in 1993.

    "Constructive" talks were held between the Armenian and Azerbaijan presidents were held this week however, the former's office said on Friday.

    Our correspondent said that Turkey and Armenia are looking towards future economic benefits of any accords, particularly the exploitation of oil and gas in the Caspian region.

    "Turkey's ambition is to be the central collecting point for all the massively important pipelines that will start to draw increasingly - as the years roll on - the so-far untapped oil and gas reserves in the area," she said.

    "It will completely change the game in this region and the fortunes of the various countries. But of course if Turkey didn't have a relationship with Armenia, it couldn't build pipelines through the area.

    "The game plan, longer term, for both countries is, this should be one of their business options."

    Al Jazeera is not responsible for the content of external websites.

    SOURCE: Al Jazeera and agencies


    Life after death row: The pastor praying for Nigeria's prisoners

    The Nigerian pastor adapting to life after death row

    Clinton Kanu spent 27 years in prison for a murder he did not commit, but life on the outside feels far from free.

    What it means to love a dead child

    What it means to love a dead child

    You must forget all you thought you knew about grief when the landscape of your life has been demolished.

    'Butchered': The Kenyan FGM clinic serving Europeans

    'Butchered': The Kenyan FGM clinic serving Europeans

    Kenya banned FGM in 2011, but Europeans still bring their daughters to underground clinics there to be cut.