Air France plane 'hit sea intact'

French investigators say jet that crashed in Atlantic "was not destroyed while in flight".

    French officials have said the search for the flight recorders would continue until July 10 [AFP]

    Alain Bouillard, who is leading the investigation on behalf of France's BEA air accident board, said: "The plane was not destroyed while it was in flight.

    "It seems to have hit the surface of the water in the direction of flight and with a strong vertical acceleration."

    Error messages 

    A food galley was found with its shelves compressed towards its base, the floor of a crew rest area was deformed and the tail fin was wrenched off the fuselage, all in ways that suggest a violent collision with the ocean, the officials said.

    In depth

     Focus: Agony for Brazil jet crash families 
    Timeline: Air France accidents 
    Profile: Airbus A330-200 

    Route map of Air France 447
     Air France jet goes missing over Atlantic

    The cause of the crash, however, is still not known.

    Bouillard said control of the flight was supposed to have passed from air traffic controllers in Brazil to their counterparts in Senegal, but that never happened.

    He said the pilots of Flight 447 tried three times to connect to Dakar, the Senegalese capital, by satellite without success.

    It was not until 0830 GMT, more than six hours after a flurry of error messages from the onboard electronic systems, that the airliner was officially declared missing by Spain, whose airspace it was due to have crossed on the way to France.

    Asked whether the alleged air-traffic fumble may have delayed the search operation, Bouillard said: "It is one of the subjects of our investigation: why so much time elapsed between the last radio contact and declaration of an emergency." 

    Brazilian denial

    Aviation officials say it is not uncommon for flights to be out of reach temporarily while crossing the stormy expanse of ocean where the jet crashed.

    But a Brazilian official denied local controllers had failed to hand over responsibility for the aircraft to Senegal.

    Henry Munhoz, a Brazilian air force spokesman, said: "The alert that there had probably been an accident was issued by Madrid.

    France has been probing the seabed with remote sonars [EPA]
    "Madrid issued that alert because the plane did not reach its airspace, but before that [the plane] had to pass through Dakar. Why was that alert not issued earlier?

    "The BEA made a preliminary interpretation that possibly Brazil did not transfer control of the flight to Dakar, but this did in fact happen.

    "We have a transcript of it, which was even sent to the BEA. We have information that Dakar did receive that transfer."

    BEA officials said Brazil had sent a "co-ordination message" advising basic details of the flight's progress but did not send a second message formally transferring control of the aircraft.

    The contrasting accounts are the second sign of friction in the aftermath of the world's worst air crash in eight years.

    The BEA also reiterated unease that France had not yet been granted access to autopsy reports on bodies taken to Brazil and said these would provide helpful clues in the investigation.

    Bouillard said the search for the flight recorders, or "black boxes", from the Airbus A330-200 aircraft would continue until July 10.

    The recorders emit a signal for around 30 days. After that, France will continue to search the seabed with remote sonars until August 15.

    No wider concerns

    Despite the disaster, investigators said they did not see any wider concerns that would indicate the need to ground Airbus A330-200 aircraft.

    Speculation has focused on incoherent speed readings provided by the jet's speed sensors, or pitot tubes, which may have disrupted other systems.

    Several problems with A330 speed sensors have been reported, including two in the US recently, but authorities say none has so far led to a significant loss of altitude.

    Families of the Air France victims said on Thursday they wanted more information on the error messages sent by the airliner in the last minutes of its flight.

    SOURCE: Agencies


    Interactive: How does your country vote at the UN?

    Interactive: How does your country vote at the UN?

    Explore how your country voted on global issues since 1946, as the world gears up for the 74th UN General Assembly.

    'We were forced out by the government soldiers'

    'We were forced out by the government soldiers'

    We dialled more than 35,000 random phone numbers to paint an accurate picture of displacement across South Sudan.

    Interactive: Plundering Cambodia's forests

    Interactive: Plundering Cambodia's forests

    Meet the man on a mission to take down Cambodia's timber tycoons and expose a rampant illegal cross-border trade.