Mexico leader condemns Arizona law

Calderon says US state's move against illegal immigrants will cause hate and discrimination.

    Laura Carlsen, director of Americas Policy Program, spoke to Al Jazeera from Mexico City:

    "Calderon has said he will not take this sitting down and has vowed to send legions of lawyers to fight this law, and defend individual cases of Mexicans in Arizona who have been subject to this law."

    She said that since the US does not participate in many of the international legal instruments, like the UN convention on the rights of migrant workers, Mexico has very little legal leverage to challenge the law directly.

    Migrant workers

    But much of Arizona's wealth and success is believed to be built on the backs of Mexican immigrants.

    "It would be difficult to understand the growth and prosperity of the United States in the 20th century without the help and contribution of Hispanic and Mexican workers," Calderon said.

    "It would also be very difficult to expect a solid economic recovery in the United States if the work of migrants is excluded in any way, because it's highly lucrative."

    Carlsen said that under Nafta, the North American Trade Agreement, there is no clause allowing for even major violations of human rights

    "What happened is that with US imports into Mexico [under Nafta], an estimated 2 million Mexican farmers were displaced and no longer able to make a living off producing farm products.

    "Now Arizona uses a massive amount of Mexican farm workers to harvest its crops.

    Calderon is to meet Barack Obama, the US president, next month in Washington DC, when he will bring up the issue, he said.

    Profiling concern

    The tough new law in Arizona, that borders Mexico, requires legal immigrants to carry documentation at all times. It is slated to be introduced 90 days after the current legislative session adjourns.

    in depth

      Mexico City's water crisis
      Targeting the Mexican media
      US closes Mexico border consulate
      Doubts cloud Mexico's war on drugs
      US alert over Mexico killings
      Reporters targeted in Mexico
      Mexico's new murder capital

    It has heightened fears that Hispanic immigrants will be racially profiled.

    "What is a father to do if, in 90 days, they can be stopped by any police officer and questioned ... when their family is at home and their kids in school?" Elias Bermudez, the founder of Phoenix nonprofit Immigrants Without Borders, said.

    "That's going to create havoc, so a lot of them are saying, 'Look, before they pick me up, I'd rather leave the state of Arizona either to another state or back home'."

    Jan Brewer, Arizona's governor, who signed the bill into law, has said that the costs of uncontrolled immigration and poor enforcement by the federal government has caused the state to act independently.

    Given the long border between Arizona and Mexico, the state has a history of tough laws that have been unsuccessful in deterring undocumented immigrants from making the short, but often perilous, journey across the desert border region.

    Obama criticised the law last week, stating that it was "misguided", and protests against it have been held outside the Arizona state capital building, which has also been vandalised.

    'Reasonable suspicion'

    More demonstrations are planned for the coming weeks against what will be the harshest anti-illegal immigration law in the US.

    The law makes it illegal to hire day labourers off the street and to transport illegal immigrants.

    It also requires state and local police to decide whether people are in the country illegally should they have "reasonable suspicion".

    There is also concern in Arizona that the new law could have an impact on tourism to the state, and Mexican leaders have previously said that it may affect bilateral ties and trade.

    The 3,200km US-Mexico border is said to be the busiest in the world. A total of about $1bn-worth of goods passes over the frontier in either direction every day and about 350 million people cross it annually.

    It is believed that there are about 10.8 million people living illegally in the US, with an estimated 460,000 in Arizona.

    The law is backed by Republicans in the state legislature and looks set to cause a standoff in November congressional elections in which the Democrats will be defending majorities in the senate and House of Representatives.

    SOURCE: Agencies


    Interactive: How does your country vote at the UN?

    Interactive: How does your country vote at the UN?

    Explore how your country voted on global issues since 1946, as the world gears up for the 74th UN General Assembly.

    'We were forced out by the government soldiers'

    'We were forced out by the government soldiers'

    We dialled more than 35,000 random phone numbers to paint an accurate picture of displacement across South Sudan.

    Interactive: Plundering Cambodia's forests

    Interactive: Plundering Cambodia's forests

    Meet the man on a mission to take down Cambodia's timber tycoons and expose a rampant illegal cross-border trade.