US army blames 'flawed' Iraq plan

US policymakers blamed for making "wrong plan" based on "wrong assumptions".

    General Tommy Franks, right, was blamed for cutting troops too soon [GALLO/GETTY]

    But in the army's own account of the occupation, senior officers now concede their calculations were sorely mistaken.

    "The assumptions about the nature of the post-Saddam Iraq on which the transition was planned proved to be largely incorrect," the report's authors say.

    Speaking to Al Jazeera, one of the report's principal authors, Colonel David Reese of the US Combat Studies Centre, said there had been a series of failings.

    "There were overly optimistic assumptions about how well Iraqi civil and local institutions of government would continue to function after Saddam was gone; and there was overoptimistic sense of how unified the Iraqi people would be when they had an opportunity to choose a new government," he said.

    The document is based on more than 200 interviews with participants in the invasion and occupation of Iraq, including the present chief of staff, General George Casey.

    'Wrong assumptions'

    "We had the wrong assumptions and therefore we had the wrong plan to put into play"

    General William Wallace,
    head of US army training and doctrine command

    Quoted in the report, General William Wallace, a senior commander, said "we had the wrong assumptions and therefore we had the wrong plan to put into play."

    The study faults both military and political leaders for focussing excessively on toppling Saddam without enough consideration of the post-Saddam transition.

    The Pentagon, it says, "did commit resources to the planning of post-invasion operations."

    But it adds: "In retrospect, however, the overall effort appears to have been disjointed and, at times, poorly coordinated, perhaps reflecting the department's ambivalence towards nation-building."

    Among the flaws the report details is a lack of detailed pre-war plans to assume the duties of Saddam's government, based on expectations that US civilian agencies would take on that task.

    Then came the order from Paul Bremer, the US chief administrator, to disband the Iraqi army and strip Ba'ath party members of their government jobs.

    That decision caught field commanders off guard and created a pool of disaffected Sunni Iraqis motivated to step up attacks on US-led occupation forces.

    Premature cutback

    The report cites a series of flawed assumptions about Iraq[EPA]
    Moreover General Tommy Franks, the top US commander, kept insisting on an early downsizing of US ground forces to less than half the number proposed by Pentagon planners before the invasion.

    The report says Franks' decision to move to a slimmed-down, short-staffed headquarters shortly after the invasion of Iraq completely took senior colleagues by surprise.

    He reportedly told his officers to be ready to cut back on forces in preparation for "an abbreviated period of stability operations".

    As a result Franks' successor, General Ricardo Sanchez, found himself suffering from staff shortages and a poor transfer of responsibilities.

    Speaking late last year Sanchez said he "saw first-hand the consequences of the administration's failure to devise a strategy for victory in Iraq that employed in a coordinated manner the political, economic and military power of the United States."

    The army study echoes many of the complaints long voiced by critics of the Bush administration.

    But in this case, coming directly from within the US military, the source of the criticism carries a special air of authority.



    SOURCE: Al Jazeera and agencies


    Interactive: How does your country vote at the UN?

    Interactive: How does your country vote at the UN?

    We visualised 1.2 million votes at the UN since 1946. What do you think are the biggest issues facing the world today?

    'We were forced out by the government soldiers'

    'We were forced out by the government soldiers'

    We dialled more than 35,000 random phone numbers to paint an accurate picture of displacement across South Sudan.

    Interactive: Plundering Cambodia's forests

    Interactive: Plundering Cambodia's forests

    Meet the man on a mission to take down Cambodia's timber tycoons and expose a rampant illegal cross-border trade.