US court dismisses Bush spying case

Court rules plaintiffs have no right to challenge eavesdropping programme.

    The Bush administration adopted the domestic spying programme after the September 11 attacks [EPA]

    The American Civil Liberties Union has led the lawsuit on behalf of other groups including lawyers, journalists and scholars it says have been handicapped in doing their jobs by government monitoring.

    However, Judge Julia Smith Gibbons, one of the appeals court's Republican appointees, said that the plaintiffs did not have standing or the legal right to sue.

    She said the plaintiffs failed to show they were subject to the surveillance and therefore do not have standing for their claims.

    'Unchecked surveillance'

    Melissa Goodman, ACLU lawyer, said the decision effectively protects the wiretapping programme, which was abandoned in January, from any judicial review.

    "The Bush administration is basically left free to violate an act of congress with impunity - the foreign intelligence surveillance act, which congress adopted over 30 years ago to prevent the executive from engaging in precisely this kind of unchecked surveillance," Goodman said.
    "They are effectively saying you can't show that you've been wiretapped and you'll never be able to show that you've been wiretapped because the whole thing is so secret."

    The dissenting voice on the three-member panel, Judge Ronald Lee Gilman, a Democratic appointee said he would uphold the ruling on the grounds that the programme violated the intelligence surveillance act law of 1978.

    A US district court in Detroit, Michigan, ruled in August last year that the programme violated the US constitution and the 1978 law prohibiting surveillance of US citizens on US soil without the approval of the special surveillance court.

    The Bush administration appealed, and a court in Cincinnati set aside the judge's decision. If the ACLU does not appeal the ruling, the case will be sent back to the judge in Michigan for dismissal.

    SOURCE: Agencies


    YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

    Interactive: Coding like a girl

    Interactive: Coding like a girl

    What obstacles do young women in technology have to overcome to achieve their dreams? Play this retro game to find out.

    Heron Gate mass eviction: 'We never expected this in Canada'

    Hundreds face mass eviction in Canada's capital

    About 150 homes in one of Ottawa's most diverse and affordable communities are expected to be torn down in coming months

    I remember the day … I designed the Nigerian flag

    I remember the day … I designed the Nigerian flag

    In 1959, a year before Nigeria's independence, a 23-year-old student helped colour the country's identity.