What do we know about Israeli captives taken by Hamas and their release?

More than 200 people, including civilians and military personnel, are still being held in different locations in Gaza.

Israelis attend a demonstration, calling for the return of loved ones who were taken as hostages following a deadly infiltration by Hamas gunmen from the Gaza Strip, in Tel Aviv
Israeli demonstrators call for the return of loved ones held in Gaza [Janis Laizans/Reuters]

More than 200 people are believed to be held captive by Hamas and other Palestinian armed groups in Gaza after the deadly attacks inside Israel on October 7.

Hamas said the attacks, which killed more than 1,500 Israelis, were aimed at ending “Israeli violations” at the Al-Aqsa Mosque compound, Islam’s third holiest site, and to secure the release of hundreds of Palestinian prisoners from Israeli prisons.

Since then, Israel has been pounding Gaza with nonstop aerial strikes, killing over 8,000 people, including over 3,000 children, and has launched a ground offensive.

So what do we know about the captives, and how many of them have been released? What are the chances for the release of the others? What do we know about Israel’s planned offensive?

Who are they?

The latest figure given by Israel’s military on Sunday was 239 people, including military personnel, were being held captive in the besieged enclave.

Hamas said on Monday an estimated 50 captives have been killed by Israeli air strikes. Earlier, they had said 20 captives had been killed.

“The murdered and the missing come from over 30 countries, including the United Kingdom,” British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak told lawmakers this month.

We don’t have all the details about the captives yet, but officials from different countries have provided some information.

Israeli authorities have not publicly named the captives so far, but a considerable number are believed to be military officers. Some are believed to be children and the elderly.

At least 10 United States citizens are still unaccounted for and are believed to be held in Gaza, according to officials.

Thailand believes it has 17 nationals among the captives, and at least eight are Germans.

Seven British nationals and seven French citizens are still classified as missing, and some are believed to be held captive. Argentina and the Netherlands have also said they have citizens held in Gaza.

Yokheved Lifshitz, 85, an Israeli grandmother who was held by Hamas in Gaza, smiles after being released at Ichilov Hospital in Tel Aviv, Israel, on October 24, 2023 [Janis Laizans/Reuters]

Who has been released?

Four people held in Gaza have so far been released by Hamas, keeping hopes alive that others may also be freed.

On October 20, a mother and daughter from Chicago who also hold Israeli citizenship were released.

Natalie Raanan, 17, and her mother, Judith, 59, were transferred to Egypt through the Rafah crossing with the help of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC). They met with Israeli security forces in Egypt and were transferred to a military base in Israel to be reunited with their family.

Qatari and Egyptian mediation led to the release of two elderly Israeli women late on Monday. Yokheved Lifshitz and Nurit Yitzhak, also known as Nurit Cooper, were released on “humanitarian” grounds, according to Hamas.

The 85-year-old Lifshitz said at a news conference on Tuesday that she was hurt during the abduction but was treated well during captivity. Both women’s husbands remain captives.

Hamas has claimed it treats the captives as “guests”.

Will others be freed?

Hamas has said it wanted to release some of the captives without conditions but Israel rejected the offer. Tel Aviv has denied this claim.

Israeli media have reported that Hamas may be on the verge of releasing more than 50 captives as advanced talks are held with Israel, which had said as it ramped up its bombing campaign that it would not talk with the “terrorist” organisation.

Reports have indicated Hamas has demanded Israel allow fuel into Gaza, a request also made by human rights organisations as hospitals are fighting to keep the lights on for thousands of wounded Palestinians.

Al Jazeera, however, could not confirm the veracity of the Israeli media reports.

In addition to Qatar and Egypt, Turkey may also emerge as a mediator after its foreign minister, Hakan Fidan, said the US and several European countries have asked for help.

In addition to talking to their governments, families have taken to social media to plead for help. There have also been rallies in several countries during which demonstrators have called for the captives’ release.

The US has sent a small special operations team to help the Israeli military with captives, but any rescue operation would be risky.

Israelis and Palestinians have a history of taking captives, and Israel has doubled its number of Palestinian prisoners to 10,000 since the Hamas attacks this month.

The most high-profile case of a prisoner exchange took place in 2011 when Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit, who was taken five years earlier, was swapped for 1,027 Palestinian prisoners.

What about the ground offensive?

Israel, which had been amassing troops and equipment on the Gaza border, has launched ground operations inside northern Gaza in recent days and its military is ready to expand them despite Iranian warnings that this will escalate the war.

However, reports indicate that US President Joe Biden has asked Israel to hold off on a large-scale attack until the captives are released, saying there is “no higher priority” at the moment.

Experts have said a ground offensive would carry high risks for the captives because there is no exact information on where they are being held. Many of them are believed to be held in a large network of underground tunnels beneath Gaza.

Much of northern Gaza has been levelled by Israeli bombing, and a ground war is expected to be difficult and unforgiving.

Source: Al Jazeera