Chile presents appeal to FIFA in World Cup case with Ecuador

FIFA expected to issue a ruling in the case of an Ecuador player that Chile claim played while ineligible during World Cup qualifying.

Ecuador's Byron Castillo in action with Argentina's Nicolas Gonzalez
Ecuador's Byron Castillo, right, in action with Argentina's Nicolas Gonzalez during World Cup qualifiers [File: Reuters]

Chile has presented its appeal challenging Ecuador’s place at the World Cup to FIFA in a case alleging an ineligible player with a ruling expected in the coming days.

Barely nine weeks before the 32-team World Cup is scheduled to start on November 20, Chile is hoping to replace Ecuador in the opening match against host Qatar. It presented its appeal on Thursday.

FIFA previously said it asked Ecuador player Byron Castillo, who Chilean officials claim is actually Colombian and should not have played in World Cup qualifying games, to be available to testify. The appeal hearing was being conducted remotely from Zurich with only the three judges present.

A verdict is expected by early next week – possibly as soon as Friday – though it is unlikely to resolve the case.

Either the Chilean or Ecuadorian football federation can appeal to the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) if they lose. CAS would then manage an urgent case in Lausanne, Switzerland.

The FIFA appeals committee rarely overturns a ruling by the football body’s disciplinary committee, which sided with Ecuador in a decision on June 10.

Castillo played in eight World Cup qualifiers and helped Ecuador advance to the tournament by placing fourth in the 10-team South American group.

Chile claims to have documents proving Castillo was never eligible to play for Ecuador and so should forfeit all eight games. That would lift Chile to fourth place and drop Ecuador out of contention.

The case is proceeding while FIFA and Qatari organisers are selling thousands of tickets and accommodation rooms to Ecuador fans.

Chile prepared its legal arguments after the World Cup draw was made on April 1, when Ecuador was put into Group A with Qatar, the Netherlands and Senegal.

The FIFA judge overseeing the case is Neil Eggleston, a former White House counsel in the second administration of former US President Barack Obama.

Source: Al Jazeera and news agencies