Egypt revises death toll from train crash to 19

Initial death toll of 32 has been revised down while number of injured has risen to 185 people, health minister says.

People inspect the damage after two trains collided near the city of Sohag, Egypt [Khaled Hasan/REUTERS]

Egypt has begun to bury the dead from a train collision that killed at least 19 people and injured 185, according to a revised toll, as investigators probed the country’s latest deadly rail crash.

Health Minister Hala Zayed told reporters on Saturday that an initial toll of 32 killed in Friday’s crash was revised down, while the number of injured rose from 165.

Surveillance camera footage of the accident seen by AFP showed a speeding train barrelling into another as it rolled slowly down the tracks, sending a carriage hurtling into the air in a cloud of dust.

Most of those injured in Friday’s crash that occurred in the Tahta district of southern Sohag province suffered fractures.

The first victims were laid to rest early on Saturday with small groups of family and friends in attendance.

President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi pledged tough punishment for those responsible for the crash, the latest in a series of rail accidents to plague Egypt.

It came as the most populous Arab nation struggles with another major transport challenge – a giant container ship blocking the Suez Canal, a vital shipping lane for international trade.

Early on Saturday Egypt was again struck by tragedy when a building collapsed in the capital, Cairo, killing at least five people and injuring 24 others, according to officials.


At the scene of the rail disaster, technicians worked through Friday evening to remove five dislocated and damaged carriages. By morning the crash area was cleared of twisted metal and debris and rail traffic had resumed.

Witnesses and survivors recounted horrifying scenes.

“We were at the mosque then a child came and told us [about the incident]. We heard the collision, so we rushed and found the carnage,” a 59-year-old man told AFP news agency, speaking on condition of anonymity.

The first ambulances to reach the scene arrived “around half an hour” after the crash, he said.

“There were children who removed [debris] using wooden ladders,” added the witness, who spent the day helping rescue workers.

People inspect the damage after two trains collided near the city of Sohag, Egypt  [Khaled Hasan/REUTERS]

One train was travelling between the southern city of Luxor and Alexandria on the Mediterranean coast, and the other between the southern city of Aswan and Cairo.

Kamel Nagi, a 20-year-old conscript, was on the Cairo-bound train after enjoying a few days of leave.

“Our train suddenly stopped and a quarter of an hour later, the second arrived and struck us,” said Nagi, who suffered multiple broken bones.

“I saw it coming, screamed, then found myself on the ground in great pain,” he said from hospital.

‘Accidents can happen’

Authorities opened an investigation to determine the circumstances of the accident, while the rail authority blamed the crash on unidentified passengers who “activated emergency brakes” in one train.

The prosecution said it would interrogate several rail employees, including the two train drivers, their assistants and the signalman. They will also have to undergo drug testing and their mobile phones have been seized by the authorities to examine their call logs, it added.

But media reports on Saturday claimed both train drivers had died of injuries sustained in the crash.

The rail authority said one train hit the last carriage of the other, causing at least two carriages to overturn between the stations of Maragha and Tahta.

Prime Minister Mostafa Madbouli said the government will disburse 100,000 Egyptian pounds (around $6,400) to each family who lost a loved one and between 20,000-40,000 pounds to those injured.

The government has spent “hundreds of billions of pounds” to upgrade the railway system over the past four years, he said, acknowledging that the network “has suffered from decades of negligence”.

Egypt’s railway network is one of the oldest in Africa and the Middle East and improving it “will take time”, Madbouli told reporters on Friday after visiting the crash site.

“Until then accidents like this can happen,” he said, adding that efforts to upgrade the system have been hampered by the coronavirus pandemic which has delayed deals with foreign firms.

A video grab taken from the Egyptian state television station shows people gathered around the wreckage of two trains that collided [Stringer/Egyptian State TV/AFP]

On Friday el-Sisi promised to punish those responsible for the deadly wreck.

“Anyone who caused this painful accident through negligence or corruption, or anything similar, must receive a deterrent punishment without exception or delay,” the president said on Twitter.

Middle East analyst Yehia Ghanem told Al Jazeera earlier that punishing low-level employees, as has occurred in the past, fails to address the structural problems with the country’s decaying rail system.

“There is a serious problem when it comes to fundamental services to the Egyptian people, including the railways. These kinds of accidents happen sometimes on a weekly basis. The responsibility falls on the system, on the regime, on the president himself,” Ghanem told Al Jazeera.

One of the deadliest Egyptian train crashes came in 2002, when 373 people died as a fire ripped through a crowded train south of Cairo.

Source: Al Jazeera and news agencies