The top prosecutor in St Louis County, Missouri announced Thursday that he will not charge the former police officer who fatally shot Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri – a dramatic decision that could reopen old wounds amid a renewed and intense national conversation about racial injustice and the police treatment of minorities in the United States.
It was nearly six years ago that a grand jury declined to indict Darren Wilson, the white police officer who shot Brown, a Black 18-year-old. Civil rights leaders and Brown’s mother had hoped that Prosecuting Attorney Wesley Bell, the county’s first Black prosecutor, would reopen the case after he took office in January 2019.
“My heart breaks” for Michael’s parents, Bell said during a news conference. “I know this is not the result they were looking for and that their pain will continue forever.”
Describing the announcement as “one of the most difficult things I’ve had to do”, Bell said that his office conducted a five-month review of witness statements, forensic reports and other evidence.
“The question for this office was a simple one: Could we prove beyond a reasonable doubt that when Darren Wilson shot Micheal Brown, he committed murder or manslaughter under Missouri law? After an independent and in-depth review of the evidence, we cannot prove that he did,” Bell said.
But, he said, “our investigation does not exonerate Darren Wilson”.
The August 2014 police shooting touched off months of unrest in Ferguson, and made the St Louis suburb synonymous with a national debate over police treatment of minorities. The Ferguson unrest helped solidify the national Black Lives Matter movement that began after Trayvon Martin, a Black 17-year-old, was shot to death in Florida in 2012.
Every one of them should be alive today.
— Congresswoman Ayanna Pressley (@RepPressley) July 10, 2020
The issue has taken on new life since George Floyd’s death in Minneapolis in May. Ferguson is among many cities around the world that have seen protests since Floyd’s death.
“This is a time for us to reflect on Michael’s life, to support Michael’s family and to honour a transformative movement that will forever be linked to his name,” Bell said.
Bell – who took office in January 2019 as a reform-minded prosecutor promising to eliminate cash bail for non-violent offenders and to increase the use of programmes that allow defendants to avoid jail time – faced no restrictions in reexamining Brown’s death for potential murder charges. Wilson was never charged and tried, so double jeopardy was not an issue. There is no statute of limitations on filing murder charges.
As the news conference drew to a close, one observer erupted in anger at Bell.
“It’s over! One term!” the man, who did not provide a name, screamed as the prosecuting attorney. Police officers gently led the man from the room.
The shooting happened after Wilson told Brown and a friend to get out of the street as they walked down the middle of Canfield Drive on a Sunday afternoon. A scuffle between Wilson and Brown ensued, ending with the fatal shot. Wilson said Brown came at him menacingly, forcing him to fire his gun in self-defence.
The ex-officer who killed Michael Brown in Ferguson, MO will not be charged, a top prosecutor says.
A grand jury failed to indict Darren Wilson in 2014, but there have been renewed calls for charges after #GeorgeFloyd was killed.
Brown's body was left in the street for 4 hrs. pic.twitter.com/MQBIzCjt60
— AJ+ (@ajplus) July 30, 2020
Brown’s body remained in the street for four hours, angering his family and nearby residents. Some people initially said Brown had his hands up in surrender when Wilson fired, although a grand jury and the US Department of Justice did not find those accounts credible.
Bell’s predecessor, longtime prosecutor Bob McCulloch, drew considerable criticism for taking the case to a grand jury rather than charging Wilson himself. Critics also accused McCulloch of swaying the grand jury to its decision not to indict Wilson – an accusation he emphatically denied. Wilson resigned days after McCulloch’s November 24, 2014 announcement that the grand jury would not indict the officer.
The Justice Department also declined to charge Wilson, but issued a scathing report citing racial bias in Ferguson’s police and courts.
Bell, a former Ferguson councilman, upset McCulloch, a staunch law-and-order prosecutor, in the 2018 Democratic primary and ran unopposed that November. Within days of taking office, Bell took steps to remove three veteran assistant prosecutors, including Kathi Alizadeh, who played a role in presenting evidence to the grand jury in the Ferguson case.
In his campaign to unseat McCulloch, Bell focused on larger criminal justice issues, not on McCulloch’s handling of the Wilson investigation.
Bell, who, like McCulloch, is the son of a police officer, said in an interview after the election that he would appoint independent special prosecutors for allegations of wrongdoing by officers. He said he would support police “200 percent” as long as they act appropriately. But he said officers who violate the law must be held accountable.
Brown’s mother, Lesley McSpadden, asked Missouri Republican Governor Mike Parson to reopen the investigation in 2018, saying Bell’s win was “a clear mandate from the people of St Louis to reform the criminal justice system, which first begins with securing justice for my son”. But Parson’s office said it had no legal authority to appoint a special prosecutor.
Calls to reopen the Brown investigation also came from Justin Hansford, executive director of the Thurgood Marshall Civil Rights Center. In an August 2019 Washington Post opinion article, he called McCulloch’s ouster “a sign of hope and change”.