Experts warn of more ‘apartheid cities’ following Delhi violence

Minority and poor people likely to be blocked from accessing housing in desirable neighbourhoods, rights experts say.

A man (R) speaks on his mobile phone as he walks past a burnt-out mosque and shops following clashes between people supporting and opposing a contentious amendment to India''s citizenship law, in New D
A mosque in Delhi's Ashok Nagar was torched and a saffron flag associated with the Hindu far right was placed on the minaret [File: Sajjad Hussain/AFP]

India risks greater segregation in its cities after deadly riots in the capital New Delhi last week, with minority and poor people likely to be blocked from accessing housing in desirable neighbourhoods, human rights experts said on Thursday.

The deadly violence in the city’s northeast – the worst Hindu-Muslim riots in Delhi in several decades – killed more than 40 people – mostly Muslims – and injured hundreds. Thousands have been displaced after their homes were torched. Many of those uprooted belong to the minority community.

The capital city of more than 20 million people is now likely to see greater segmentation along religious lines as has happened in other Indian cities, such as Mumbai and Ahmedabad, said Miloon Kothari, a housing and human rights expert.

“We generally see greater ghettoisation in a city after a riot because of fear and insecurity, with city authorities themselves sometimes reorganising neighbourhoods that entrench that segregation,” he told the Thomson Reuters Foundation.

“Apartheid cities are being created due to political, planning and gentrification processes that divide communities further, impoverish the poor, and makes it easier to target vulnerable communities again.”

Displacements caused by flooding, beautification of cities, and big sporting events such as the 2010 Commonwealth Games in New Delhi and the 2016 Rio Olympics, also led to ghettoisation of the poor, said Kothari, a former United Nations special rapporteur for adequate housing.

Delhi has long drawn migrants from neighbouring states, who often live in informal settlements because of high rents.

Like in other Indian cities, Delhi’s informal rules and deep-rooted biases also discriminate against religious minorities and even unmarried people, or those with certain food preferences or professions.

Ghetto or mixed neighbourhood

Deadly communal clashes in Mumbai in 1992-93 and in the western city of Ahmedabad in 2002, led to Muslims being pushed out of mixed neighbourhoods to the fringes of the city, said Darshani Mahadevia, a professor at the Ahmedabad University.

“The Muslim poor especially … choose to live in all-Muslim neighbourhoods because they feel insecure,” she said on the sidelines of a land conference in Delhi.

“Segregation keeps the communal pot boiling for political reasons also,” Mahadevia said, citing a law in the western state of Gujarat that restricts Muslims and Hindus from selling properties to each other in areas deemed as sensitive.

Often, minority neighbourhoods have poor infrastructure and inadequate housing, said Mahadevia, adding that residents also face difficulties securing bank loans and even taxi rides.

The choice between living in a “ghetto or mixed neighbourhood” was a difficult one for many Muslims, writer and journalist Ghazala Wahab said on Twitter this week.

Families often had to weigh the risk of their home being torched against a better life, said Wahab, whose own family moved to a more modern “Hindu” area from a ghetto – where conditions had since worsened.

“That’s not living, that’s just existing,” she said.

Source: Reuters