Boeing abandons outlook, takes $1bn cost hit in MAX crisis

Lowered production due to the grounding of its 737 MAX jet after fatal plane crashes cost the company $1bn so far.

Boeing 737 Max
A file photo dated June 21, 2017 shows Boeing 737 Max flies during the 52nd International Paris Air Show at Le Bourget Airport near Paris [Reuters]

Boeing Co on Wednesday abandoned its 2019 financial outlook, halted share buybacks and said lowered production due to the grounding of its fastest-selling 737 MAX jet after two fatal plane crashes in five months had cost it at least $1bn so far.

The world’s largest planemaker is facing one of the biggest crises in its 103-year history following the disasters on Lion Air in Indonesia on October 29 and another on Ethiopian Airlines on March 10, which together killed all 346 on board.

Chicago-based Boeing is now reckoning with a blow to its reputation and the financial cost of getting the planes back in the air. It met sharply lowered Wall Street profit estimates for the first quarter, largely due to stopping deliveries of the money-spinning 737 MAX jets and a slowdown in production.

The production dip alone has cost it $1bn so far, the company said, because the lower rate means the planemaker has to pay more for parts, which are priced according to the volume Boeing buys.

Boeing also booked unspecified charges related to developing a software fix for an anti-stall system that Boeing has acknowledged played a role in both crashes, and pilot training.

Chief Executive Officer Dennis Muilenburg told analysts on a conference call that Boeing had confidence in its software fix and expected a certification flight with the US Federal Aviation Administration in the “near term” after completing more than 135 test and production flights.

He did not give a timeline for when the MAX would fly again commercially, saying the timing “will continue to be paced” by global regulators and airlines. He defended the company’s aircraft development process but indicated he was open to improvements. 


“If there’s something that we can do to make plane development programs or the certification process better and safer, we will pursue it,” Muilenburg said.

Reuters reported on Tuesday that Boeing told some 737 MAX owners it was targeting FAA approval of its software as early as the third week of May, and the ending of the grounding around mid-July, when it could resume building 52 aircraft per month.

Repairing the brand

A fuller picture of how much the grounding will cost Boeing and how it plans to repair its image with the flying public will not emerge until the end of the second-quarter as 737 production cuts did not begin until mid-April. 


“Boeing had little new to provide on how exactly the 737 MAX situation is likely to pan out,” said Vertical Research Partners analyst Robert Stallard. “We think a return to flight in August is probably optimistic, but September is possible.”

Muilenburg said the company did not see any changes to the underlying certification process for its all-new 777X twin-aisle airliner in light of the MAX crashes and said the programme remained on track for delivery in 2020. Boeing continues to work “in parallel” on plans for a potential new mid-sized plane, although Muilenburg stressed the 737’s return was a higher priority.

He also defended his role as both CEO and chairman of Boeing after calls from some shareholders that the jobs be divided.

Boeing shares closed up 0.4 percent at $375.46. They are still down about 10 percent since the Ethiopian Airlines crash, wiping almost $25bn off the company’s market value.

Defends 737 MAX development

The crashes caused regulators worldwide to ground the 737 MAX and triggered investigations into the aircraft’s development by federal transportation authorities and the US Department of Justice. 


Although safety experts have raised some questions over crew performance in both crashes, attention has focused on anti-stall software known as MCAS, which Boeing has acknowledged was a common link in the separate chains of events leading to both crashes.

Muilenburg insisted on Wednesday that “there was no surprise or gap or unknown here or something that somehow slipped through the certification process” but added that a board committee would review the company’s aircraft development processes.

“We know exactly how the airplane was designed. We know exactly how it was certified,” he said. “We’ve taken the time to understand that. That has led to the software update that we’ve been implementing and testing and we’re very confident that when the fleet comes back up, the MAX will be one of the safest airplanes ever to fly.”

Boeing cut production of the jets following the MAX grounding to 42 aircraft per month, down from 52, and its operating cash flow in the first quarter was around $350m lower than a year earlier.

Boeing also removed 210 aircraft from its order backlog and took an impairment charge over customer financing losses following the near-collapse of India’s Jet Airways.

Boeing said it would issue a new financial forecast when it knows more about issues surrounding the 737 MAX. In January, it said it expected full-year revenue of $109.5bn to $111.5bn and core earnings per share between $19.90 and $20.10.

The company repurchased $2.3bn of its shares in the latest quarter, all of which occurred prior to mid-March. Boeing bought back $9bn of its stock last year.

First-quarter operating cash flow declined to $2.79bn, from $3.14bn, missing the Wall Street’s average estimate of $2.82bn.

Revenue fell two percent to $22.92bn, below analysts’ average estimate of $22.98bn.

Excluding certain items, Boeing said its core earnings fell to $3.16 per share, in the quarter from $3.64 per share, a year earlier. That matched analysts’ average estimates.

Source: Reuters