European court urges release of prominent Turkish activist

ECHR says there is a lack of reasonable suspicion that businessman Osman Kavala had committed an offence.

Members of the European Court of Human Rights listen at the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, France, 31 October 2017. French President Macron visited the European Court of Human Rights.
The court said it supported Kavala's assertion that his detention was aimed at silencing him. [File: Jean-Francois Badias/EPA]

The European Court of Human Rights has called for the immediate release of Turkish businessman and activist Osman Kavala, saying there was a lack of reasonable suspicion that he had committed an offence.

Kavala has been in jail in Turkey for more than two years while on trial on charges of attempting to overthrow the government, based on accusations that he organised and funded nationwide protests in 2013 against then-Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who currently holds an empowered presidential seat.

The indictment cited tapped phone calls in which Kavala discussed sending pastries, milk, juice and gas masks to protesters as evidence that he financed the protests. Kavala, who faces life in jail if convicted, has denied the allegations.


The court said on Tuesday that the authorities were unable to demonstrate that the applicant’s pretrial detention had been justified by reasonable suspicions based on an objective assessment of the acts attributed to him.

“In the absence of facts, information or evidence showing that Mr Kavala had been involved in criminal activity, he could not reasonably be suspected of having attempted to overthrow the Government by force or violence,” the court said, calling on authorities to secure his release.

It also said in the ruling that it supported Kavala’s assertion that his detention was aimed at silencing him, adding that it was “likely to have a dissuasive effect on the work of human rights defenders”.

ECHR rulings are legally binding, but Turkey has frequently not implemented them. There was no comment from the Turkish government on Tuesday’s ruling.

Kavala should ‘return to freedom’

Three of Kavala’s lawyers said the ECHR’s ruling was a “just but delayed legal achievement.”

“We strongly emphasise the steps needed to be taken without losing time to ensure that our client Osman Kavala returns to freedom at once in line with this ruling,” they said in a statement.

Lawyer Ilkan Koyuncu told the Reuters News Agency that the Turkish court can rule to release Kavala by itself after the ECHR ruling but that the lawyers will also apply for his release.


Critics of Erdogan’s government have questioned the independence of Turkish courts, especially since a crackdown following a failed coup in 2016. Erdogan and his government say the judiciary makes independent decisions.

The demonstrations in 2013 started as a protest against the redevelopment of Gezi Park in Istanbul and quickly spread across the country.

Kavala at the time sat on the board of the Turkish branch of financier George Soros’s Open Society Foundation. He has said the charity did not provide financial support to the protests.

The next hearing on his case is set for December 24 and 25. Fifteen other defendants are on trial along with Kavala, who is currently the only one in jail.

Source: Al Jazeera, News Agencies