Spain accused of excessive force at Catalonia protests

Rights group reviewed three cases where security forces used disproportionate force during Catalonia referendum.

Spanish Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy Speaks At The Spanish Parliament
Mariano Rajoy has given Catalonia five days to clarify its position on independence [Pablo Blazquez Dominguez/Getty Images]

Human Rights Watch has accused Spanish police officers of using excessive force against civilians during Catalonia’s referendum on secession from Spain. 


Security forces – including the Spanish Civil Guard and National Police Corps – used batons and shields to strike and charge at peaceful protesters causing multiple injuries, according to a report by the rights group released on Thursday.

“Our detailed investigation into three cases found that national police and Civil Guard officers used excessive force on October 1 in Catalonia,” said HRW’s Kartik Raj.

“The police may well have had the law on their side to enforce a court order but it didn’t give them the right to use violence against peaceful protesters.”

HRW documented the excessive use of force by officers in the cities of Barcelona and Girona, and received a number of other allegations regarding ill-treatment of protesters by police.

The organisation called on officials from Catalonia and the Spanish government to “cooperate fully with an independent investigation into the violence”.

Nearly 900 people were injured during the region’s disputed vote on secession from Spain on October 1, according to regional and national authorities. More than 400 police officers were also injured.

The report comes as Spain prepares to celebrate its National Day on Thursday, despite the ongoing political crisis. 

Five-day ultimatum

The separatist movement secured a 90-percent vote in favour of independence but a unionist boycott of the vote meant turnout stood at just 43 percent.

Spanish Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy has given Catalonia’s President Carles Puigdemont five days to clarify whether or not he has declared the region independent.

Puigdemont suspended any declaration of independence to allow for talks with the central government in Madrid during a speech to the Catalan regional parliament on October 10. 

Spain’s media spin on Catalonia – The Listening Post

Article 155 of the Spanish constitution allows the central government in Madrid to take direct control of any of the country’s 17 autonomous regions – of which Catalonia is one – if they are deemed to be breaking the law.

Spain’s constitutional court ruled to suspend the referendum last month, on the grounds that the country’s 1978 Constitution states Spain is indivisible and gives the national government the exclusive power to hold referendums.

Catalonia is home to 7.5 million people and has a distinct culture, history and language. The region is one of the wealthiest in Spain, accounting for a fifth of the country’s economic output. Historical disputes and economic grievances have strengthened the cause of independence for the region.

Catalans previously voted in favour of seceding in a non-binding referendum in 2014, with 80 percent in favour.

Source: Al Jazeera