Massachusetts: 21,000 drug cases could be dismissed

Former police chemist falsified tests, which could lead to biggest 'dismissal of criminal convictions in US history'.

    Former police chemist Annie Dookhan falsified test results for nearly 10 years [Jessica Rinaldi/Reuters]
    Former police chemist Annie Dookhan falsified test results for nearly 10 years [Jessica Rinaldi/Reuters]


    • Former police chemist Annie Dookhan caught tampering evidence, falsifying tests
    • Rights group says 21,587 cases are in question
    • Dookhan admitted testing fraction of batches, jailed for three years
    • Case comes as justice department moves to disband non-partisan NCFS
    • Scientists concerned forensics will be overseen by law enforcement

    More than 21,000 convicted drug offenders in the US state of Massachusetts may have their cases dismissed because a former police chemist tampered with evidence and falsified tests.

    If the cases are thrown out, the event would mark the largest dismissal of criminal convictions in US history, according to the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Massachusetts.

    The state's highest court had ordered district attorneys in seven counties to produce lists by Tuesday indicating how many of approximately 24,000 cases involving Annie Dookhan they would be unable or unwilling to prosecute if the defendants were granted new trials.

    The cases would be formally dismissed by court action, expected on Thursday, the ACLU said.

    "Today is a major victory for justice and fairness, and for thousands of people in the commonwealth who were unfairly convicted of drug offences," Matthew Segal, legal director of the ACLU of Massachusetts, said on Tuesday. 

    US justice department to scrap forensic science panel

    An investigation in 2013 found that Dookhan falsified test results as far back as 2004.

    Prosecutors said Dookhan admitted "dry labbing," or testing only a fraction of a batch of samples, then listing them all as positive for illegal drugs.

    Her motive, they said, was to lift her productivity and reputation. She was sentenced to three years in prison and was paroled last year.

    WATCH: Flawed Forensics

    Some of those convicted lost their jobs or homes while others were deported, said Anthony Benedetti, chief counsel of the Committee for Public Counsel Services.

    "In many respects the damage has been done," Benedetti said. "Justice delayed is justice denied."

    Others have already completed their sentences.

    But wiping away their convictions will help them in other ways, such as employment, housing or immigration status, said Daniel Marx, a lawyer who argued for the dismissals.

    "Now, a majority of these wrongfully convicted individuals will have the opportunity to clear their records and move on with their lives," he said.

    Courtroom science

    While the Massachusetts case highlights the perils of poor courtroom science, the justice department is ending a partnership designed to improve scientific evidence.

    Attorney General Jeff Sessions is disbanding the non-partisan National Commission on Forensic Science (NCFS), thereby ending the department's cooperation with independent scientists appointed to raise forensic science standards.

    WATCH: Under The Microscope - The FBI Hair Cases

    Sessions has also suspended an NCFS review into the evidence that was used in cases that have now closed.

    Attorney General Jeff Sessions is disbanding the non-partisan National Commission on Forensic Science [Aaron P Bernstein/Reuters]

    Some scientists are concerned that forensics will now be overseen by law enforcement authorities, as opposed to the non-partisan NCFS.

    The commission has found that FBI experts often overstated the accuracy of their evidence.

    That analysis has changed standards for what is allowed in court.

    "There have been a lot of people let out of jail after many years ... because of some evidence that was refuted later on," Bill Lidinsky, director of the forensics laboratory at the Illinois Institute of Technology, told Al Jazeera.

    In March, Keith Harward was freed from a Virginia prison after 33 years on rape and murder charges he did not commit. Two dentists said his teeth matched bite marks on the victim.

    Forensics now regard bite mark matches as unreliable, and question whether other courtroom science should also be reviewed.

    SOURCE: Al Jazeera and news agencies


    Interactive: How does your country vote at the UN?

    Interactive: How does your country vote at the UN?

    We visualised 1.2 million votes at the UN since 1946. What do you think are the biggest issues facing the world today?

    'We were forced out by the government soldiers'

    'We were forced out by the government soldiers'

    We dialled more than 35,000 random phone numbers to paint an accurate picture of displacement across South Sudan.

    Interactive: Plundering Cambodia's forests

    Interactive: Plundering Cambodia's forests

    Meet the man on a mission to take down Cambodia's timber tycoons and expose a rampant illegal cross-border trade.