Russia: UN Syria resolution protected ‘terrorists’

Russia calls failed French draft resolution “politicised and one-sided” while Egypt gets flak for Security Council vote.

Russian Deputy Defence Minister Antonov speaks during news briefing on situation in Syria at Russian Defense Ministry in Moscow
Russia said it is 'ready to keep searching for a long-term Syria solution' [Maxim Zmeyev/Reuters]

The Russian foreign ministry says a draft French UN Security Council resolution on Syria would have helped “terrorists” in the Aleppo area by protecting them from aerial bombing.

In a statement published on Sunday, as Syrian government forces pressed on with their offensive against rebel fighters in the city, the Russians said the French text was “politicised and one-sided”.

“An explicit attempt was made, by banning flights in the Aleppo area, to provide cover for the terrorists of Jabhat al-Nusra and associated militants,” the ministry said.

Western powers and Russia clash at UN over Syria

But it also emphasised that Russia is “ready to keep searching for a long-term Syria solution, despite its differences with the West”.

The UN Security Council voted on Saturday on two rival resolutions on the fighting – one drafted by France calling for an end to air strikes and a second by Russia that urged a ceasefire but made no mention of halting the bombings.

Russia’s text was effectively the French draft with Russian amendments.

It removed the demand for an end to air strikes on Aleppo and put the focus back on a failed US-Russia ceasefire deal which was annexed to the draft.

Russia vetoed the French-drafted resolution while the Russian draft failed to gather enough votes to pass.

OPINION: Syria – Do people really care?

Matthew Rycroft, Britain’s ambassador to the UN, described Saturday’s failure in New York as “a bad day for Russia, but an even worse day for the people of Aleppo”.

“Russia has become one of the chief purveyors of terror in Aleppo, using tactics more commonly associated with thugs than governments,” David Pressman, US deputy ambassador to the UN, told the council.

He said Russia was “intent on allowing the killing to continue and, indeed, participating in carrying it out” and that what was needed from Moscow was “less talk and more action from them to stop the slaughter”.

‘Theatrical mess’

A UN resolution needs nine votes in favour and no vetoes to be adopted. The veto powers are the US, France, Britain, Russia and China.

The French draft received 11 votes in favour, while China and Angola abstained. Venezuela joined Russia in voting against it.

The Russian text received only four votes in favour, so a veto was not needed to block it.

UPFRONT: Has the UN failed in Syria?

Russia only gained the support of China, Venezuela and Egypt for its draft resolution.

Angola and Uruguay abstained, while the remaining nine council members voted against.

Inside Syria – UN on Syria: Must a million die?

Egypt was the only Security Council member to vote for both the French and the Russian plans.

It drew criticism from Saudi Arabia and Qatar for its apparent support of Moscow’s proposal.

Abdullah al-Alami, Saudi Arabia’s representative for the UN, said on Saturday: “It was very painful that Senegal and Malaysia were closer to the Arab consensus on Syria, compared to that of Egypt, which is supposed to be the Arab representative to the Security Council.

“The counter-proposal by Russia was a theatrical mess.

“Today is a dark day for Syria, but the Syrian people won’t give up. They will prevail against the odds.”

INSIDE STORY: What has Russia accomplished in Syria?

Qatar, too, expressed disappointment over Egypt’s vote with Russia, and said it would push ahead with plans to address the humanitarian situation on the ground in Syria.

White Helmets praised for humanitarian role in Syria

“We were disappointed when Egypt voted for the Russian proposal,” Alya bint Ahmed bin Saif Al Thani, Qatar’s ambassador to the UN, told Al Jazeera on Saturday.

“It’s important now to focus on what we can do after the failure of the Security Council – this is the fifth veto by Russia concerning Syria.

“We will now work with the countries that are friends with the Syrian people to look at what the options are.”

Al Jazeera’s Diplomatic Editor James Bays, reporting from the UN headquarters in New York City, said there are only a few diplomatic options left to halt the suffering of the Syrian people.

“The International Syria Support Group, all the key international and regional players have got nowhere,” he said.

“Then there were efforts by the US and Russia. They’re now not talking to each other. And the last-ditch option was trying to get the Security Council to take a lead – they’ve now hit a roadblock.”


“There is one final initiative led by Security Council member New Zealand that may succeed in securing a ceasefire in Aleppo in the coming days.

“New Zealand’s ambassador Gerard van Bohemen already has its own draft text and he’s consulting with other countries to get a last-minute effort to get agreement around the Security Council table.”

‘Decisive land offensive’

Meanwhile, on the ground, Syrian government forces have kept up their assault on rebel-held eastern Aleppo on Sunday.

The soldiers and their allies were advancing on Sunday street by street in the eastern sector, which has been out of government hands since 2012.

“Clashes on the ground as well as fierce air strikes went on all night and are continuing on Sunday, especially in the Sheikh Said district” of eastern Aleppo, said Rami Abdel Rahman, head of the UK-based Syrian Observatory for Human Rights monitoring group.

Syria: Under Russia’s fist – People and Power

It said government forces took control of the Jandul crossroads in the northeast of Aleppo.

The latest advances aim to clear the way for “a crucial and decisive land offensive”, said the Damascus daily Al Watan, which is close to the government.

The army launched its assault on the besieged sector of Aleppo more than two weeks ago with the backing of Russian air strikes, aiming to reunite the city which was Syria’s economic hub before its conflict erupted in 2011.

According to the SOHR, air strikes by the government and its Russian ally have claimed 273 lives, mostly civilians and including 53 children, since the September 22 launch of operations to reunite the government-held west and the east of Aleppo.

Another 17 civilians have died in artillery bombardment of eastern districts, said the monitoring group.

The SOHR, which compiles its information from sources on the ground, said 50 civilians, including nine children, have also died in rebel bombardment of regime-controlled western districts.

READ MORE: Syria’s war – John Kerry wants war crimes probe

The assault on Aleppo was launched just days after the collapse of a ceasefire in Syria which was brokered jointly by Russia and the US.

Frank-Walter Steinmeier, German foreign minister, warned that the mounting tensions between the US and Russia over the Syrian conflict had created a situation “more dangerous” than the Cold War.

“It’s a fallacy to think that this is like the Cold War,” he said in an interview published by Bild newspaper. “The current times are different and more dangerous.”

Syria’s civil war: Russia’s bombing campaign one year on

Source: Al Jazeera, News Agencies