Yahoo wants China case dismissed

Company says it was acting under Chinese law by handing over dissidents’ details.

Critics says Yahoo sacrificed human rights to commercial profit [EPA]
Critics says Yahoo sacrificed human rights to commercial profit [EPA]

Human rights groups have accused Yahoo of co-operating with Beijing by supplying it with email records and IP addresses of several activists who used its service and who were later imprisoned.


The Yahoo motion comes in response to a case brought against the company earlier this year under human rights laws in San Francisco‘s federal court.


In it, the company said it had “obeyed a lawful government request for the collection of evidence relevant to a pending investigation”.


“Every sovereign nation has a right to regulate speech within its borders”


Yahoo said it “does not condone the suppression of their rights and liberty by their government”, but it added that they were responsible for their own actions.


“They assumed the risk of harm when they chose to use Yahoo! China email and group list services to engage in activity they knew violated Chinese law,” it said.


“Free speech rights as we understand them in the United States are not the law in China,” it added.


“Every sovereign nation has a right to regulate speech within its borders. It is a political case challenging the laws and actions of the Chinese government.”




Journalist Shi Tao was arrested and jailed for
10 years by Chinese authorities [AP]

It also warned that filing the lawsuit in California “might well be viewed as a profound rebuke” of the Chinese government, “and risk poisoning US relations with a significant world power”.


Morton Sklar, the dissidents’ lawyer, argued the company was liable even if its actions took place in China.


“US corporations are not bound just by the laws of their host countries, but also the laws of the United States and standards of conduct that are placed upon them by the United States, and by the international community,” Sklar told the San Francisco Chronicle.


Wang, Wang’s wife and Shi are seeking unspecified monetary damages, an injunction preventing Yahoo from complying with China‘s future requests for similar private information, and help to secure Wang and Shi’s release from prison.


Yahoo has said that the Chinese authorities do not reveal reasons for seeking information about its users and do not disclose names of individuals being targeted.




Wang, an editor of several journals calling for political reform, was arrested at home in 2002.


The lawsuit alleges that Yahoo provided the authorities with his email records, which included pro-democracy writings he had sent anonymously to others, including some overseas.


Wang was sentenced to 10 years in a Beijing prison on charges of trying to subvert the government and establish an alternative to the Communist party.


His wife, Yu Ling, said he has been beaten, kicked and threatened while in prison.


Shi, a journalist, was arrested in 2004 and convicted of sending word of a media crackdown to the New York website Democracy Forum. He is also serving a 10-year sentence.

Source : News Agencies


A Hong Kong lawmaker says he has filed a complaint with Hong Kong’s privacy commission alleging that Yahoo’s Hong Kong arm provided evidence to convict a Chinese reporter sentenced to 10 years in prison for leaking state secrets.

31 Mar 2006
More from News
Most Read