Skip linksSkip to Content
play
Live
Navigation menu
  • News
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • US & Canada
    • Latin America
    • Europe
    • Asia Pacific
  • Middle East
  • Explained
  • Opinion
  • Sport
  • Video
    • Features
    • Economy
    • Human Rights
    • Climate Crisis
    • Investigations
    • Interactives
    • In Pictures
    • Science & Technology
    • Podcasts
play
Live

In Pictures

Gallery|Conflict

In Pictures: Family in cave home faces Israeli eviction

Ahmed Amarneh says as a natural formation, Israel could not possibly argue his cave home was illegally built.

Ahmed Amarneh, stands by a tap at the kitchen of his home which he built in cave, in the village of Farasin, west of Jenin, in the northern occupied West Bank on August 4, 2020. - Amarneh, a 30 year o
Ahmed Amarneh, 30, stands in the kitchen of his cave home. Amarneh, a civil engineer, lives with his family in the northern West Bank village of Farasin, where Israel insists it must approve any new residential construction and can tear down homes built without permits. [Jaafar Ashtiyeh/AFP]
Published On 11 Aug 202011 Aug 2020
facebooktwitterwhatsappcopylink

Ahmed Amarneh’s home, its wooden door leading into cushion-lined rooms, is not the first Palestinian residence in the occupied West Bank to receive a demolition notice from Israel.

But it may be the first built inside a cave that Israel has threatened to destroy.

Amarneh, a 30-year-old civil engineer, lives with his family in the northern West Bank village of Farasin, where Israel insists it must approve any new residential construction and can tear down homes built without permits.

“I tried twice to build [a house], but the occupation authorities told me it was forbidden to build in the area,” said Amarneh.

The Oslo peace accords of the 1990s gave the Palestinians self-rule in parts of the West Bank. However, about 60 percent of the territory dubbed Area C, where Farasin is located, remains under full Israeli civil and military control.

 

The United Nations considers Area C as occupied Palestinian territory. But Israel has increasingly taken land there for the construction of Jewish settlements – considered illegal under international law.

‘Didn’t make the cave’

Convinced he would never get Israeli approval to build a home in his village, Amarneh set his sights on a cave in the foothills overlooking Farasin.

Amarneh said he figured that because the cave is a natural formation, Israel could not possibly argue it was illegally built, while the Palestinian Authority agreed to register the land in his name.

Amarneh sealed the mouth of the cave with a stone wall and installed a wooden door at its centre.

Advertisement

He fashioned a kitchen, a living room, and sleeping areas for himself, his pregnant wife, and their young daughter. There is even space for guests.

After living there for a year and a half, he received a demolition notice from the Israeli authorities in July along with 20 other Palestinian families in Farasin.

The Israeli military branch responsible for civilian affairs in the occupied West Bank, COGAT, said demolition notices were served to some Farasin residences because of “structures that were illegally built, without the necessary permits and approvals”.

Amarneh said he was “surprised” to learn that he had built anything illegally.

“I didn’t make the cave. It has existed since antiquity,” he said, holding his young daughter in his arms.

 

“I don’t understand how they can prevent me from living in a cave. Animals live in caves and are not thrown out. So let them treat me like an animal and let me live in the cave.”

Israeli bulldozers

Arab residents established the village of Farasin in 1920, said local council head, Mahmud Ahmad Nasser.

It was abandoned during the 1967 War, the year the Israeli occupation of the West Bank began. But from the 1980s, former residents began to return to the area. Nasser put its current population at about 200.

Farasin looks less like a village than a small collection of houses spaced widely apart.

The PA officially recognised the community of Farasin in March, but the coronavirus crisis has prevented it from providing electricity to the area, the local council said.

COGAT indicated in April it might suspend some scheduled demolitions because of the pandemic.

But, according to the Israeli anti-settlement campaign group B’Tselem, Israel demolished 63 Palestinian structures in June.

Roughly 450,000 Jewish settlers live in the occupied West Bank, alongside some 2.7 million Palestinians.

Farasin residents have feared the arrival of Israeli bulldozers for weeks, Amarneh said.

Recently soldiers came and told Palestinian people “they had one minute to collect all their things” and leave their house, he said.

“They told us, without any shame, to leave the village.”

Amarneh is fearful that his family’s cave home could be the next target, adding that his wife and daughter are “in shock”.

Ahmed Amarneh throws his daughter beneath a skylight hole as they play together at his home, built in cave in the village of Farasin, west of Jenin, in the northern occupied West Bank on August 4, 202
Amarneh plays with his daughter beneath a skylight. His home is not the first Palestinian residence in the occupied West Bank to receive a demolition notice from Israel. But it may be the first home built inside a cave the Jewish state has threatened to destroy. [Jaafar Ashtiyeh/AFP]
Advertisement
Sheep feed in a make-shift enclosure inside a cave housing the home of Ahmed Amarneh, in the village of Farasin, west of Jenin, in the northern occupied West Bank on August 4, 2020. - Amarneh, a 30 ye
Sheep feed in a makeshift enclosure inside the cave. [Jaafar Ashtiyeh/AFP]
The wife of Ahmed Amarneh holds her daughter at their home built in cave, in the village of Farasin, west of Jenin, in the northern occupied West Bank on August 4, 2020. - Amarneh, a 30 year old civil
After a year and a half living in the cave, Amarneh and his family received a demolition notice from the Israeli authorities in July, along with 20 other Palestinian families in Farasin. [Jaafar Ashtiyeh/AFP]
Ahmed Amarneh (L), and family members share a meal at his home built in cave, in the village of Farasin, west of Jenin, in the northern occupied West Bank on August 4, 2020. - Amarneh, a 30 year old c
"I tried twice to build [a house] but the occupation authorities told me it was forbidden to build in the area," says Amarneh. [Jaafar Ashtiyeh/AFP]
Ahmed Amarneh and his wife prepare coffee at his home, built in cave in the village of Farasin, west of Jenin, in the northern occupied West Bank on August 4, 2020. - Amarneh, a 30 year old civil engi
Amarneh said he figured that because the cave is a natural formation, Israel could not possibly argue it was illegally built, while the Palestinian Authority agreed to register the land in his name. [Jaafar Ashtiyeh/AFP]
Ahmed Amarneh and a neighbour chat outside his home, built in cave in the village of Farasin, west of Jenin, in the northern occupied West Bank on August 4, 2020. - Amarneh, a 30 year old civil engine
Amarneh sealed the mouth of the cave with a stone wall and installed a wooden door at its centre. [Jaafar Ashtiyeh/AFP]
Advertisement
The daughter of Ahmed Amarneh crawls on a carpet at his home built in cave, in the village of Farasin, west of Jenin, in the northern occupied West Bank on August 4, 2020. - Amarneh, a 30 year old civ
Amarneh says he was "surprised" to learn he had built anything illegally. "I didn't make the cave. It has existed since antiquity." [Jaafar Ashtiyeh/AFP]
Ahmed Amarneh (R), and family members sit on cushions at his home built in cave, in the village of Farasin, west of Jenin, in the northern occupied West Bank on August 4, 2020. - Amarneh, a 30 year ol
"I don't understand how they can prevent me from living in a cave. Animals live in caves and are not thrown out. So let them treat me like an animal and let me live in the cave." [Jaafar Ashtiyeh/AFP]


    • About Us
    • Code of Ethics
    • Terms and Conditions
    • EU/EEA Regulatory Notice
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy
    • Cookie Preferences
    • Sitemap
    • Work for us
    • Contact Us
    • User Accounts Help
    • Advertise with us
    • Stay Connected
    • Newsletters
    • Channel Finder
    • TV Schedule
    • Podcasts
    • Submit a Tip
    • Al Jazeera Arabic
    • Al Jazeera English
    • Al Jazeera Investigative Unit
    • Al Jazeera Mubasher
    • Al Jazeera Documentary
    • Al Jazeera Balkans
    • AJ+
    • Al Jazeera Centre for Studies
    • Al Jazeera Media Institute
    • Learn Arabic
    • Al Jazeera Centre for Public Liberties & Human Rights
    • Al Jazeera Forum
    • Al Jazeera Hotel Partners

Follow Al Jazeera English:

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • youtube
  • instagram-colored-outline
  • rss
Al Jazeera Media Network logo
© 2025 Al Jazeera Media Network