Skip linksSkip to Content
play
Live
Navigation menu
  • News
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • US & Canada
    • Latin America
    • Europe
    • Asia Pacific
  • Middle East
  • Explained
  • Opinion
  • Sport
  • Video
    • Features
    • Economy
    • Human Rights
    • Climate Crisis
    • Investigations
    • Interactives
    • In Pictures
    • Science & Technology
    • Podcasts
play
Live

In Pictures

Gallery|Human Rights

India’s ‘people of nowhere’

Thousands of Hindus from Pakistan have fled to India, but face high barriers to citizenship and a decent life.

Refugee_1.jpg
Following the partition in 1947, asylum seekers from newly created Pakistan flowed into India.
By Showkat Shafi
Published On 20 Jun 201320 Jun 2013
facebooktwitterwhatsappcopylink

Jodhpur, Rajasthan– India and Pakistan won their independence in 1947, but the year also left deep scars by leaving hundreds of thousands without a nation to call their own.

Millions of people migrated and fled their homes during the partition that lead to the formation of the two countries. Even after six decades of independence religious minorities, mostly Hindus, have been fleeing Pakistan and migrating to India, claiming harassment. Some left for better economic opportunities. Most of the families have stationed themselves in India’s western state of Rajasthan, which borders Pakistan.

For Halmal Bheel, 54, who had migrated in 2000, settling down in India has been tough. “This is our land, and we are not refugees here,” he said. “My father migrated to Pakistan, but our ancestral land and the remains of our old house are still here. So it really hurts when someone calls us refugees or Pakistanis.”

Hindu Singh Sodha, an activist working with Hindu immigrants from Pakistan, said “nobody is bothered about plight of these people. Both central and state government prefer to ignore their situation … The only thing these people have been demanding is the grant of a refugee status. The government does not want to take the ownership, so as to avoid the provision of basic facilities like food and shelter to the immigrants.” 

The Indian government has toughened the requirements to attain citizenship: migrants must now live in the country for seven years before being eligible to become a citizen, up from five years; and the application fee for citizenship has greatly increased.

Advertisement

And the places where these immigrants live often lack basic necessities like water, good food and electricity. “It is very hard to live in such conditions. We do not get cooking gas connections, electricity connections, and cannot even apply for a driving license. The basic human needs are also not provided to us,” said Gordhan Bheel. “All we want is either a refugee status or grant of Indian citizenship.”

Khushala Ram, 50, who came to India in 2009 on a pilgrim visa and has remained in the country, said: “I will never go back. I came with the hope that the Indian government will accept us with open hearts, but I do not know why they have been treating us as Pakistanis. We are Indians who have come back home.”

Sodha, the activist, said the refugees “have not illegally entered the country, as they own valid passport and visas. Most of those who have come to seek shelters are Bheel tribals with little representation in the government or bureaucracy. Not just poor come from Pakistan, but also some rich business-class people arrive having money and bureaucratic contacts [and] end up getting citizenship easily. It is all about money.” 

Refugee_2.jpg
The asylum seekers, many of whom live in dire poverty, often identify with India - not Pakistan - as their country.
Advertisement
Refugee_3.jpg
Unhygienic conditions in these temporary living spaces often lead to the spread of epidemic diseases.
Refugee_4.jpg
Jodhpur, a city in India(***)s western Rajasthan state, is home to thousands of Pakistani immigrants.
Refugee_6.jpg
In India the migrants are often ostracised and labelled as Pakistanis.
Refugee_8.jpg
They have little access to water, good food, electricity and other essential amenities.
Refugee_9.jpg
These refugees often live in makeshift homes to bear the harsh desert climate of Rajasthan.
Advertisement
Refugee_11.jpg
Migrants use pilgrims’ visas to enter India, with no intention of returning to Pakistan. 
Refugee_12.jpg
There are many Pakistani-Hindu immigrant settlements in Jodhpur, with more than 7,000 people living without citizenship from any country.
Refugee_13.jpg
Maha Kumbha Mela, a Hindu pilgrimage, and other ceremonies open opportunities for these immigrants to obtain a visa.
Refugee_14.jpg
The pre-requisite fee for applying for citizenship has been greatly increased, making it very difficult for them to obtain Indian citizenship.
Refugee_15.jpg
Many mothers give birth to children in makeshift homes due to a lack of available medical facilities.
Refugee_16.jpg
The migrants consider themselves “people of nowhere”: they have left Pakistan for India, in search of a home that isn(***)t accepting them.
Refugee_17.jpg
These immigrants aren(***)t given refugee status, and obtaining Indian citizenship often seems nearly impossible.
Refugee_18.jpg
The minimum time a migrant must live in India before attaining citizenship has been increased from five years to seven years.
Refugee_19.jpg
Some immigrants have been waiting for more than a decade to get Indian citizenship.
Refugee_20.jpg
Although living conditions are grim for these immigrants, they are hopeful for a better future.


    • About Us
    • Code of Ethics
    • Terms and Conditions
    • EU/EEA Regulatory Notice
    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy
    • Cookie Preferences
    • Sitemap
    • Work for us
    • Contact Us
    • User Accounts Help
    • Advertise with us
    • Stay Connected
    • Newsletters
    • Channel Finder
    • TV Schedule
    • Podcasts
    • Submit a Tip
    • Al Jazeera Arabic
    • Al Jazeera English
    • Al Jazeera Investigative Unit
    • Al Jazeera Mubasher
    • Al Jazeera Documentary
    • Al Jazeera Balkans
    • AJ+
    • Al Jazeera Centre for Studies
    • Al Jazeera Media Institute
    • Learn Arabic
    • Al Jazeera Centre for Public Liberties & Human Rights
    • Al Jazeera Forum
    • Al Jazeera Hotel Partners

Follow Al Jazeera English:

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • youtube
  • instagram-colored-outline
  • rss
Al Jazeera Media Network logo
© 2025 Al Jazeera Media Network