US gender pay gap persists even in top roles, study finds

Even women who make it to the top ranks of United States corporations face a persistent pay gap compared with men in leadership roles, a new study of corporate filings found.

Among companies in the Russell 3000 Index, covering most of the investable US stock market, the highest-paid women earned 84.6 cents for every dollar earned by male counterparts in 2019, up from 81.5 cents in 2015, according to a paper from researcher Morningstar Inc due out on Wednesday.

Author Jackie Cook said the narrower difference pointed to progress that should continue as companies file disclosures in coming weeks showing 2020 compensation.

But the persistent gap reflects a lack of top female leaders – and shows how those now in place often hold lower-paid posts such as heads of marketing or human resources. To change, companies must add more women at all levels to maintain a diverse pool for promotions, she said.

“Companies can’t just solve for this at the top of the ladder, they have to look at the entirety” of their workforces, Cook said.

Her analysis traced five years of pay disclosures by 2,384 Russell 3000 companies from 2015 to 2019. Most recently, women held just 12 percent of the “named executive officer” positions, up from 9 percent in 2015. At companies in the sample, 47 percent had at least one woman in their top ranks in 2019, up from 35 percent in 2015.

The female executives were still well paid, with median compensation of $1.76m in 2019, and their gap with male counterparts narrowed faster than did the pay gap for working women overall.

According to the Center for American Progress, a Washington think-tank, the 52.1 million US women who worked full time and year-round earned 82 cents for every dollar earned by men in 2019, up from 80 cents in 2015.

Gender and race-based pay differences have received more attention amid social justice protests and the brutal economic impact of the COVID-19 pandemic.

A recent report from the National Women’s Law Center found 2.3 million women left the US labour force since the start of the pandemic, leaving their participation rate at 57 percent, the lowest since 1988.

Women have made faster gains in corporate boardrooms, where the percentage of Russell 3000 directors who are women stood at 23 percent as of November, according to researcher Equilar. Boardroom diversity has been a bigger focus of asset managers and directors can serve at more than one company.

Morningstar’s Cook pointed to a number of high-profile companies with no women listed among top-paid executives as of 2020, including online retailer Amazon.com, the third-most valuable US company, and State Street Corp, the asset manager known for its “Fearless Girl” campaign.

Asked about Cook’s study and comment, an Amazon representative noted a report on the company’s website that found women at Amazon earned the same pay as men “performing the same jobs”. The page also states, “We continue to prioritize pay equity”.

In a statement e-mailed by a spokesman, State Street said it remains “focused on representation of women and other underrepresented groups particularly in senior, higher-paying roles demonstrated by women comprising 29 percent of our management committee and four of our 11 directors.”