The World Bank said its board on Thursday adopted a new plan to aid China with $1-$1.5bn in low-interest loans annually through June 2025, despite the objections of United States Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin and several US legislators.
Mnuchin told a House Financial Services Committee hearing that the Treasury’s representative on the board had objected to the plan, adding he wants the World Bank to “graduate” China from its concessional loan programmes for low- and middle-income countries.
The five-year lending strategy plan was published on Thursday afternoon after the World Bank’s board “expressed broad support” for the multilateral development lender’s engagement in China’s structural and environmental reforms.
The World Bank said its lending would decline over the “country partnership framework” plan, in line with reforms agreed based on a $13bn capital increase agreed in 2018.
The World Bank loaned China $1.3bn in the 2019 fiscal year ending on June 30, down from about $2.4bn during fiscal 2017.
The new plan calls for lending to “gradually decline” from the previous five-year average of $1.8bn.
“Lending levels may fluctuate up and down from year to year due to normal pipeline management based on project readiness,” the World Bank said.
It added Beijing had requested continued financing from the World Bank’s International Bank for Reconstruction and Development division “as platforms for reform, institution building and knowledge transfer.”
‘A dollar is too much’
But the decline in lending is not fast enough for Mnuchin, who has argued China is too wealthy for such international aid, when it is lending hundreds of billions of dollars of its own to poor countries through its Belt and Road infrastructure drive.
US legislators are also increasingly expressing concerns that US taxpayer funds loaned through the World Bank to China will enable human rights abuses and unfair economic competition with the US.
In Senate floor remarks on Thursday, Senate Finance Committee Chairman Charles Grassley cited alleged human rights abuses in Xinjiang associated with detention camps for Muslim Uighurs in criticising the World Bank lending plan.
“The World Bank, using American tax dollars, should not be lending to wealthy countries that violate the human rights of their citizens and attempt to dominate weaker countries either militarily or economically,” Grassley said.
Representative Anthony Gonzalez, a Republican from Ohio who has introduced legislation to curb World Bank funding to China, added: “For me, even a dollar is too much for our taxpayers to be contributing to China.”
Although the US holds effective veto power over significant board decisions such as capital increases and leadership appointments, the latest China lending plan did not require a formal vote.
Mnuchin told legislators he expected the World Bank’s lending to China to fall below one billion dollars during the current fiscal year, with more repayment funds flowing back to the lender from China than loan funds going out.
The World Bank said the lending to China in the five-year plan would be aimed at advancing market and fiscal reforms to encourage private sector development; promoting greener growth by reducing pollution and reducing carbon emissions; and increasing Chinese citizens’ access to health and social services.