Comments: Talking to the enemy | News | Al Jazeera

Comments: Talking to the enemy

A selection of comments sent to us in response to Mohamed El-Moctar El-Shinqiti's editorial: Talking to the enemy.

    The problem with American policymakers is that they want other people to "look like them, talk like them, walk like them [Anglo-Saxon Americans]" while at the same time enslaving other people and not practicing what they preach.


    Roberto, US

     

    I wonder why Islam is always the misunderstood religion by many.
    Nebiha, Ethiopia

     

    It all seems so simple and clear, yet American policymakers just cannot seem to grasp it. It gladdens me to see that Esposito of Georgetown, where I am a student, is a voice for reason. 

     

    How can your message and Esposito's message are disseminated amid all the bias and misinformation in the American media and realm of public discussion? 

    John Ryan, US

     

    I think most Americans would rather see Muslims rule the Arab world, without our intervention.

     

    I think George Bush would also prefer this to losing our soldiers' lives. We would like to work together to resolve terrorism, however, we will not have innocent civilians attacked, and neither should the Arab world.

     

    We all agree that human life is too precious. We do need to have our military and intelligence services work with yours, as Saudi Arabia and Jordan are doing.

    David Cantril, US

     

    What the US is doing in the Middle East and with Islam is just what we've been doing for decades if not longer with Communism and nationalist movements in Asia, Latin America, and indeed, the whole world. 

    So the US is generally confused about the rest of the world, and our foreign policy is the result: violent yet conquering nothing.

    Christopher Rushlau, US

     

    Mohamed El-Moctar El-Shinqiti has written a very interesting article but I am surprised by his ending. America and the West should "help Muslims overcome this painful metamorphosis, and to minimise intervention in this transitional process".

    What is this?

    Is not this an illustration of the impact and influence of a Western mindset upon a Muslim who has been exposed too long?

    The problem is the West. The problem is that contact with the alien culture of the West and its facade of humanism and so-called democracy is more like a cancer that not only will spread but will destroy the body that it occupies.

    Jerry Copeland, US

     

    It is strange that America is supposed to support freedom of religion; they practice that inside America, but outside the borders it appears not.

    D Jermano, China

    SOURCE: Aljazeera


    YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

    Interactive: Coding like a girl

    Interactive: Coding like a girl

    What obstacles do young women in technology have to overcome to achieve their dreams? Play this retro game to find out.

    America's Guns: Secret Pipeline to Syria

    America's Guns: Secret Pipeline to Syria

    How has the international arms trade exacerbated conflict in the Middle East? People and Power investigates.

    I remember the day … I designed the Nigerian flag

    I remember the day … I designed the Nigerian flag

    In 1959, a year before Nigeria's independence, a 23-year-old student helped colour the country's identity.