Mexican woman battles Coke, wins

Mexico has imposed its biggest anti-monopoly fines ever, totalling about $68 million, against Coca Cola and dozens of its distributors and bottlers.

    Coca Cola now faces some of the highest anti-trust fines ever

    The battle was won by one woman who got tired of being told what to sell at her one-room store in an impoverished Mexico City neighbourhood.

    In a country where David vs Goliath battles usually end with David getting crushed, Raquel Chavez's victory is no small feat.

    Chavez's victory resulted in fines of at least US$15 million, and was quickly followed by another fine in a separate case of US$53 million, according to legal documents provided to The Associated Press by the plaintiffs.

    A spokesman for the Federal Competition Commission who was not authorised to give his name confirmed the amounts, which are being appealed and by policy will not be publicly announced until the appeals are over.

    The spokesman said the fines were the largest the commission had levied for monopolistic practices, but he could not cite the next highest.

    Coca-Cola Export Corp., the Mexican subsidiary to Coca-Cola Co., based in Atlanta, would only be liable for a small part of any fines that survive the appeal process.

    Coca-Cola responsibility

    Coca-Cola bottlers and distributors would be responsible for the rest, although it wasn't clear exactly how much.

    It is no coincidence that the battle - which resulted in some of the highest antitrust fines Coke has ever faced - was waged in Mexico, with the highest per-capita soft drink consumption in the world.

    Even Chavez, 49, expected to lose when a Coke distributor told her to get rid of Big Cola, an upstart brand that arrived in Mexico recently from Peru, or risk having Coke stop selling to her.

    "I told them, 'You can't refuse to sell to me. That's unconstitutional'," Chavez told The Associated Press. "I didn't really know if it was unconstitutional, but I said it anyway."

    Coke denial

    Coca Cola denied that it has engaged in monopolistic practices.

    "As we stated before, we respect the ... decisions," spokesman Charlie Sutlive said. "However, we have used the appeal processes open to us to present arguments that our business practices comply with Mexican competition laws, and to demonstrate that our commercial practices are fair."

    "You may call the shots everywhere else, but I'm the boss in my store"

    Raquel Chavez,
    Mexican shop owner

    Coke, whose share of the Mexican soft drink market hovers around 70%, is a must-have item for small stores.

    Chavez still sells it. But she also resented being told what she could sell.

    "You may call the shots everywhere else, but I'm the boss in my store," she told the distributor.

    She put her three children through college with her 20-hour days at her store, called La Racha, which means a streak of luck, and takes pride in the business.

    Tough business

    In 2003, her customers began asking for Big Cola, which had begun cutting into Coke's market with lower prices. Coke told her to get rid of the brand, but she refused.

    "I am a common citizen who demands her rights, who won't allow herself to be stepped on, that's all," the vigorous, fast-talking Chavez said as she sat on an upturned Coke crate outside her shop.

    "I am a common citizen who demands her rights, who won't allow herself to be stepped on, that's all"

    Raquel Chavez,
    Mexican shop owner

    The shop is tucked into the corner of a one-storey brick building in the working-class Iztapalapa neighbourhood.

    Its counters are protected against thieves with steel mesh. Doing business here is tough.

    Chavez has been held up at gunpoint or with knives several times since she opened the store in 1992. But nothing had prepared her for the fight with Coca Cola.

    Government help

    First, she did not know which government agency to turn to. Then, Chavez found the Federal Competition Commission offices on the swanky west side of town. After two months of inaction, she blew up at the anti-monopoly agency.

    "I told them, 'What are you good for? What purpose do you serve?'" she said. "Are you here to protect Coke, or to defend us?"

    They finally accepted her complaint, investigated it, and found evidence of similar incidents - some documented by Big Cola, which later joined the case.

    Two years later, on 4 July, the commission ruled in a closed-door session that 15 Coke bottlers had violated anti-monopoly laws in the case, and fined them about US$15 million.

    "I was sure we would lose, because in Mexico for so long, people got away with anything," Chavez said.

    Similar case

    Just a few weeks later, on 12 August, a similar case that had been held up in hearings for years was suddenly resolved - again, with a ruling against Coke, this time against 54 distributors who were ordered to pay about $1 million each, the maximum fine allowed.

    Mexico has the highest soft drink
    consumption in the world

    A copy of one of the rulings obtained by The Associated Press showed that some Coke distributors had threatened to remove company-supplied refrigerators and displays from shops that sold other brands.

    They also allegedly shifted competitors' merchandise away from prime locations in some stores, bought it all up and dumped it, or offered Coke merchandise in return for not selling the other brands.

    Alfredo Paredes, the communications director for Big Cola's parent company, Ajemex, credits the rulings with "giving us a sense of reassurance ... that these small business owners will no longer be subject to intimidation".

    Chavez will not get any of the money - the fines go to the government - though her victory did not come cheap.

    Dark days

    For three months, she lost all her Coke deliveries. "I thought we were going to go out of business," she said.

    "I thought that we would lose this case, and when we did, it was going to be like 'Look, little ant, we crushed you,' because the powerful always win"

    Raqul Chavez,
    Mexican shop owner

    Chavez was forced to buy Coke from wholesale centres and lug home dozens of cases in her 1979 Dodge Dart.

    "My husband just watched me," she said. "He was mad."

    Things have changed since those dark days.

    Her husband now waits on customers as Chavez proudly shows off her court papers. Almost on cue, a bright red Coke truck pulls up and smiling, courteous Coke employees unload Chavez's twice-weekly delivery. They say she is a good customer.

    "I thought that we would lose this case, and when we did, it was going to be like 'Look, little ant, we crushed you,' because the powerful always win," she said. "Now I feel proud. Maybe now people will start standing up for themselves."

    SOURCE: Agencies


    'We were forced out by the government soldiers'

    'We were forced out by the government soldiers'

    We dialled more than 35,000 random phone numbers to paint an accurate picture of displacement across South Sudan.

    Interactive: Plundering Cambodia's forests

    Interactive: Plundering Cambodia's forests

    Meet the man on a mission to take down Cambodia's timber tycoons and expose a rampant illegal cross-border trade.

    Pakistan's tribal areas: 'Neither faith nor union found'

    Pakistan's tribal areas: 'Neither faith nor union found'

    Residents of long-neglected northwestern tribal belt say incorporation into Pakistan has left them in a vacuum.