Europe in new banana dispute

Bananas may cast a shadow over world trade talks this year as EU negotiators argue with Latin American suppliers over how much they should pay to get their fruit into Europe.

    The WTO famously arbitrated during the EU-US banana wars

    Bananas, worth billions of dollars on world markets and a key revenue-earner for many Latin American countries, are the world's second-largest fruit market after citrus and have a long history in Europe as a particularly sensitive area.
    After losing the bitter banana wars of the 1990s at the World Trade Organisation, the EU pledged to scrap its complex system of quotas and import duties for a tariff-only system to run from January 2006. The problem is how high to set the duty. 

    While the EU wants a new tariff of 230 euros ($296) a tonne, producers in Latin America and in Europe's former African, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) colonies - the EU's two main banana suppliers - say that level is unacceptable. 
    Suppliers' demand

    ACP suppliers, whose fruit enters EU markets free of duty, want the tariff to be at least 275 euros to prevent cheaper Latin bananas from flooding Europe. The ACP group includes top African producers Ivory Coast and Cameroon, and Caribbean suppliers such as the Windward Islands.

    After weeks of dithering by Latin America, which wants 75 euros or less, it looks as if the gloves have now come off.

    The present banana battle pits
    the EU against Latin America

    Six Latin countries led by the world's top exporter Ecuador asked the WTO recently to step in and say if a 230-euro duty will preserve their existing share of Europe's banana market.

    The problem is that the WTO is unlikely to give its view before late July. Then, the EU may have to propose a new duty, which may - or may not - satisfy the Latin Americans. If not, they can ask for a second round of WTO arbitration.
    For the European Commission (EC), which negotiates EU foreign-trade policy, a second request would be a nightmare scenario as there would be little time to wrap up the talks before the new banana regime comes into force.
    No guarantee

    WTO arbitration can take several months, with no guarantee at the end that all sides are happy.

    "We would like to have it sorted out in mid-September so we have time to take it through the council. And that won't be an easy debate," an EC official said.

    "We would like to have the WTO case sorted out
    in mid-September"

    European Commission official

    If the process drags on, this would cast a shadow over a key WTO meeting on the Doha Round of trade talks scheduled for Hong Kong in December where the EU, and the US, are likely to face pressure to make more cuts in farm support programmes.

    One month before that, EU ministers will debate a reform of the sugar regime, a much-criticised subsidy system that has survived virtually untouched since its birth in the late 1960s.

    The EC makes no secret of the fact that it wants to go to the Hong Kong meeting with deals on bananas and sugar.
    But diplomats and industry insiders say the EC's desired timeframe may be a little ambitious, believing a second round of WTO arbitration is almost a certainty.
    The EU is the world's largest importer of bananas.

    SOURCE: Reuters


    How different voting systems work around the world

    How different voting systems work around the world

    Nearly two billion voters in 52 countries around the world will head to the polls this year to elect their leaders.

    How Moscow lost Riyadh in 1938

    How Moscow lost Riyadh in 1938

    Russian-Saudi relations could be very different today, if Stalin hadn't killed the Soviet ambassador to Saudi Arabia.

    The peace games: Dreaming big for South Sudan's youth

    The peace games: Dreaming big for South Sudan's youth

    A relatively new independence and fresh waves of conflict inspire a South Sudanese refugee to build antiwar video games.