Basque storm at Spanish film festival

Politics and sport are never far from the surface in Spain, and the 51st San Sebastian International Film Festival is no exception.

    Basque Pelota tackles thorny issue of the separatist struggle

    About 160 films are showing at the event which opened on Thursday and will run to September 27.

    But none is likely to court more controversy than Julio Medem's 115-minute offering Basque Pelota, the Skin against the Stone. The film is due to be shown at the Festival on Sunday.

    Pelota is a game in which the players strike a ball with their hands within a walled court.

    But storm clouds are brewing about the work, which owes rather more to intense political debate, Basque-style, than sport.


    After a private showing of the film, professor Gotzone Mora and journalist and writer Inaki Ezquerra, both of Basque origin and interviewed in the movie, accused Medem of "manipulating Spanish history" and of "exalting nationalism".

    More than 800 people have died
    in separatist-related violence

    They believe the film glorifies violence and is sympathetic towards the armed Basque separatist group ETA, which has killed more than 800 people in a three-decade struggle for independence in the Basque region of northern Spain.
    Medem retorted by saying he would "not respond to the criticisms until the showing" of the film.
    He left it to viewers to "work out my true intentions".

    ‘Invitation to dialogue’

    Those intentions, he maintains, are bringing to the screen a film which is an "invitation to dialogue" based on a rejection of violence.
    Festival organisers have allowed the film into the line-up saying that they do not see the work as an "vindication for terrorism".

    "(The film) lacks objectivity and constitutes a manipulation of history"

    Gotzone Mora,
    Basque professor


    Publicity material for the media attending the event says that Medem's film "analyses the situation in the Basque country in honest and dispassionate fashion, posing questions about the past, present and future of Euskal Herria (Basque for the Basque country.)
    "In presenting a large number of interviews with Basques, much archive  material and a superb soundtrack (Medem) offers a documentary which will leave nobody indifferent," says the PR spiel.

    ‘Biased and offensive’
    But Mora and Ezquerra remain far from convinced.
    They have branded the film as "biased and offensive for those under threat (of ETA violence). It furthermore portrays the police as torturers."
    Mora and Ezquerra added they were horrified by the film's release for showing at the Festival.

    Basque nationalist protest: The
    topic is Spain's most divisive issue

    "It is a biased film which presents the Spanish state as the enemy of the Basque country, the Spanish Civil War (of 1936-39) as a war between Spain and the Basque country and the (Spanish) constitution and monarchy as being imposed upon the Basque people.
    "It lacks respect for the victims (of the violence)," added Mora, referring to those who had died since ETA began its armed struggle in 1968.

    Legal threat

    In an interview with Friday's ABC daily, Mora accused Medem of "having planned a documentary as a justification of violence," saying the film "lacks objectivity and constitutes a manipulation of history."

    Mora and Ezquerra have threatened to sue the producers if the movie is released with their interviews included.

    Spanish Interior Minister Angel Acebes reacted to the controversy by saying that "nobody is alien to the struggle against terrorism."

    He added that anyone who believed in democratic values should not provide even "minimal" succour to ETA.

    However, Oskar Matute of the hard left Basque EB-IU coalition in the Basque autonomous parliament spoke out in favour of the film, accusing opponents of its showing as "trying to curtail freedom of expression."



    Interactive: How does your country vote at the UN?

    Interactive: How does your country vote at the UN?

    Explore how your country voted on global issues since 1946, as the world gears up for the 74th UN General Assembly.

    'We were forced out by the government soldiers'

    'We were forced out by the government soldiers'

    We dialled more than 35,000 random phone numbers to paint an accurate picture of displacement across South Sudan.

    Interactive: Plundering Cambodia's forests

    Interactive: Plundering Cambodia's forests

    Meet the man on a mission to take down Cambodia's timber tycoons and expose a rampant illegal cross-border trade.