EU constitution in crisis

The European Union's convention opened its latest session on Thursday facing an uphill battle to please all sides of the constitutional debate.

    D'Estaing: wants to know where
    EU is heading

    With the clock ticking down to an EU summit on 20 June in the Greek city of Salonika, convention chairman Valery Giscard d'Estaing has threatened to throw in the towel if there is no compromise in the two-day session in Brussels.
    The former French president had high hopes for a constitution being generally approved with the main players on the 105-member convention.

    But 18 of the 27 countries taking part in the convention upset the bid for consensus by lining up to reject any institutional changes to how the EU votes. 

    Countries suspicious of too much European integration, such as Britain, Scandanavian nations and eastern European countries that have only recently obtained their soverigntiy from the Soviet Union, have resisted many proposals.
    The impasse led French Foreign Minister Dominique de Villepin to declare the convention was in "crisis". 
    Decision time

    While receiving the Charlemagne Prize for fostering European unity last week, D'Estaing said Europe will be "damned" to lose its economic and cultural vigor unless it answers the question of where it is heading.

    The time has come, he suggested, to decide if Europe is to be merely a free-trade zone or something more, something he called "a community of destiny."  

    Last month Giscard d'Estaing presented proposals including a full-time president to replace the EU's rotating leadership, an EU foreign minister, a slimmed-down European Commission and a new simplified voting system.
    The plans sparked anger notably from smaller EU states which fear even greater domination by the EU heavyweights, and from the Commission which fears having its executive powers cut. 

    "The big member states claim that the European Union today needs new institutions," said Finnish government representative Teija Tiilikainen.
    "We think for our part that there is no need to change the community method, which has the served European Union very well," she said. 

    EU family not agreeing on house

    The battle lines have also been drawn over proposals to end national vetoes in more areas of decision-making, which Britain for one firmly opposes.
    Federalists claim the whole veto system, already unwieldy with 15 members, would simply seize up when 10 more countries join in May next year.
    The convention is due to hold its final session next week. Its draft constitution will then be taken up by the heads of government and thrashed out by an inter-governmental conference starting in the autumn.

    Constitution proposals

    • Council presidency : The European Council, grouping national leaders, would elect a president or chairman for a term of up to five years.     

    • Commission : The size of the Commission would be one member for each country, currently some countries have two.    

    • Foreign minister :

      The EU foreign minister would control the foreign aid budget, and conduct diplomacy. The minister would be a vice-president of the Commission, with access to its financial resources.   

    • Decision making : Decision-making on most issues would be by majority voting.    

    • Mutual defence clause :

      The constitution would contain a general solidarity clause providing for mutual assistance in case of attack.

    • Economic governance : Members of the euro single currency would be able to set and police their own economic policy guidelines and enforce budget deficit limits without the involvement of non-euro states.


    How different voting systems work around the world

    How different voting systems work around the world

    Nearly two billion voters in 52 countries around the world will head to the polls this year to elect their leaders.

    How Moscow lost Riyadh in 1938

    How Moscow lost Riyadh in 1938

    Russian-Saudi relations could be very different today, if Stalin hadn't killed the Soviet ambassador to Saudi Arabia.

    The great plunder: Nepal's stolen treasures

    The great plunder: Nepal's stolen treasures

    How the art world's hunger for ancient artefacts is destroying a centuries-old culture. A journey across the Himalayas.