Unliked: Singapore orders Facebook to correct user’s post

Singapore instructed Facebook on Friday to publish a correction notice on a user’s social media post under a new ‘fake news’ law, raising fresh questions about how the United States-based social media giant will adhere to government requests to regulate content.

Singapore’s government said in a statement that it had issued an order requiring Facebook “to publish a correction notice” on a November 23 post which contained accusations about the arrest of a supposed whistle-blower and election rigging.

Singapore said the allegations were “false” and “scurrilous” and initially ordered user Alex Tan, who runs the States Times Review blog, to issue the correction notice on the post. Tan, who does not live in Singapore and says he is an Australian citizen, refused and authorities said he is now under investigation.

Facebook declined to comment and Tan’s post was unaltered as of mid-afternoon on Friday.

This is the first time Singapore’s new law, named the Protection from Online Falsehoods and Manipulation Act, has been invoked against a digital platform.

The law was first used on November 25 against Singaporean political figure Brad Bowyer for questioning the independence of state investment firms.

Facebook has been under fire in recent years for its lax approach to fake news reports, state-backed disinformation campaigns and violent content spread on its services, prompting calls for new regulations around the world.

It has also frequently been criticized for being too willing to do the bidding of governments in stamping out political dissent.

Facebook often blocks content that governments allege violate local laws, with nearly 18,000 cases globally in the year to June, according to the company’s “transparency report”.

But the new Singapore law is the first to demand that it publish corrections when directed to do so by the government, and it remains unclear how it plans to respond to the order.

The case is the first big test for a law that was two years in the making and came into effect last month.

The Asia Internet Coalition, an association of internet and technology companies in the region, called the law the “most far reaching legislation of its kind to date”, while rights groups have said it could undermine internet freedoms, not just in Singapore, but elsewhere in Southeast Asia.

Facebook has previously said it was “concerned with aspects of the new law which grant broad powers to the Singapore executive branch to compel us to remove content they deem to be false and to push a government notification to users”.

In the only other case under the law, which covers statements that are communicated in the country even if they originate elsewhere, opposition political figure Bowyer swiftly complied with a correction request.

The penalties range from prison terms of as much as 10 years or fines up to 1 million Singaporean dollars ($735,000).

Singapore, ruled by the People’s Action Party since independence in 1965, is widely expected to hold a general election within months, although no official date has been set.