Don't idealise a secular state. Secularists in the Middle East have nothing to do with secularists in the West - all the secularists in the Middle East were dictators.
Has the Arab Spring turned into an Islamist winter?
Mehdi Hasan challenges Islamic intellectual Tariq Ramadan on the principles and practice of political Islam.
Together they dissect the Arab revolts, focusing on Egypt, the Muslim Brotherhood’s rise and demise, and the subsequent military coup.
So, has political Islam failed in Egypt? Did the Muslim Brotherhood miss its chance? And should the West be wary of Islamism?
Joining the discussion are: Anas Altikriti, a supporter of the Muslim Brotherhood and president and founder of the Cordoba Foundation; Yasmin Alibhai Brown, a journalist and the founder of British Muslims for Secular Democracy; and Professor Alan Johnson, from the pro-Israeli lobby group, BICOM.
Read the full transcript of Head to Head - Has political Islam failed? here
Watch other episodes of Head to Head
Has political Islam failed? with Tariq Ramadan will be broadcast on March 21, at 20:00 GMT and will be repeated on March 22 at 1200 GMT, March 23, at 0100 GMT and March 24, at 0600 GMT.
Join the conversation on Facebook and on Twitter