Middle East
Lebanon war report faults Olmert
Winograd commission finds "severe failure in judgment, responsibility and caution".
Last Modified: 30 Apr 2007 21:47 GMT

The commission said responsibility for the war's failures lay with Olmert, Peretz and Halutz

A commission probing Israel's war in Lebanon last summer has accused the country's wartime leaders of "very severe failures" in their handling of the conflict in an interim report.
The Winograd commission, appointed by Ehud Olmert, the prime minister, found he did not have a "well-processed plan" when he launched the campaign against Hezbollah.
The commission on Monday criticised what it called Olmert's "severe failure in judgment, responsibility and caution" in going to war last July.
Upon receiving the report, Olmert said "failures will be remedied" and has since said he has "no intention of resigning".
The report capped a six-month investigation into the conflict, which has been widely perceived as a failure by the Israeli public.


'Overly ambitious'


Your Views

"The problem is not the leaders of Israel but instead it is the Israeli society, it is the Israelis who vote and elect those leaders..."

Politics , Cambridge, United Kingdom

Send us your views

Eliyahu Winograd, chairman of the inquiry commission, said the prime minister's declared aims in going to war - to free captured Israeli soldiers and crush Hezbollah - were "overly ambitious and impossible to achieve".


The report also sharply criticised Amir Peretz, the defence minister, and Lieutenant-General Dan Halutz, the wartime military chief, but did not call for Olmert or Peretz to resign.


Israel went to war after Hezbollah fighters killed three soldiers and captured two others in a cross-border raid. In 34 days of fighting, Israel failed to return the captured soldiers, destroy Hezbollah or prevent the group from firing thousands of rockets into Israel.


Monday's report criticised Peretz for his inexperience and lack of familiarity with the army, and said Halutz "acted impulsively" and misrepresented the army's readiness.


Winograd said: "We establish that these decisions and the way they were taken suffered from the most severe failures. We put the responsibility for these failures on the prime minister, the defence minister and the former chief of staff.


"If any one of them had acted in a different, better way, the decisions and the way they were made in the period in question, as well as the results of the campaign, would have been different and better."


Sinking support


Although Olmert's popularity has plunged to single digits as a result of the war and a series of scandals plaguing his government, he said he would not resign the post of prime minister.


Timeline: Lebanon war

-  July 12, 2006: Hezbollah fighters crossed into Israel, killing eight soldiers and capturing two others.

  Ehud Olmert called the action an act of war and blamed the Beirut government.

- July 13: Israel launched airstrikes on Beirut's International Airport, the first of many attacks on Lebanon's civilian infrastructure.

  Hezbollah started a series of rocket attacks, hitting Haifa in northern Israel.

- July 14: Israeli planes bombed the Beirut offices of Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah.

  The next day airstrikes were extended to other cities starting with Tripoli.

- July 30: An Israeli raid on a building housing refugees in Qana in southern Lebanon killed at least 28.

- August 14:  With Israeli troops still in position in southern Lebanon, a UN-brokered ceasefire came into force.

  By then more than a thousand Lebanese civilians had been killed as well as 39 Israeli civilians and 119 soldiers.

In a brief televised statement from his office on Monday, he said: "It would not be correct to resign."


Instead, he said, he would work to implement the conclusions of the inquiry report, calling a special cabinet session for Wednesday to begin the work.

The full commision report is to be released in a couple of months.


Jacky Rowland, Al Jazeera correspondent in Jerusalem, said: "The wording of the report was much more severe than was expected.


"We understand that even people in the prime minister's circle were shocked."


The report covers the first six days of the war, when Israel battered Lebanon with massive air strikes as Hezbollah pounded Israel with rockets. The report also looks at developments in the six years leading up to the conflict, beginning with Israel's pullout from southern Lebanon in 2000 and tracing Hezbollah's build-up along the border.


A rally calling for Olmert and his government to quit was planned for Thursday in Tel Aviv. The demonstration was being organised by a former general, military reservists who fought in the war and parents of soldiers killed in the conflict.


Rowland said the report is likely to damage Olmert's standing further.
"One newspaper said his standing was somewhere between critical and terminal," she said.


The report's harshest criticism though, is reserved for Halutz, who has already resigned, Rowland said.
At least 1,200 Lebanese, including an estimated 270 Hezbollah fighters were killed in the summer war, as well as 119 Israeli soldiers and 39 civilians.
Al Jazeera and agencies
Topics in this article
Featured on Al Jazeera
More than one-quarter of Gaza's population has been displaced, causing a humanitarian crisis.
Ministers and MPs caught on camera sleeping through important speeches have sparked criticism that they are not working.
Muslim charities claim discrimination after major UK banks began closing their accounts.
Italy struggles to deal with growing flood of migrants willing to risk their lives to reach the nearest European shores.
The seizure of the Tabqa airbase highlights the Islamic State's consolidation of power in eastern Syria, analysts say.
Traditional spring festival blossoms outside India through fun runs, raves and TV commercials.
Parents unable to look after children are marrying them off at a tender age, exposing them to maternal deaths.
New measures needed as dozens of citizens fighting with Islamic State pose home-grown terror threat, PM Abbott says.
Israel has re-arrested dozens of Palestinians in the West Bank, an act a human rights group says is 'unjustified'.
join our mailing list