French terrorism laws criticised
Human Rights Watch says laws too broad, with many arrests based on little evidence.
Last Modified: 02 Jul 2008 17:00 GMT
The report criticised the practice of holding suspects for up to six days with little legal counsel [AFP]

A Human Rights Watch (HRW) report has said France's laws for prosecuting terrorism suspects are too broad, with too many arrests based on minimal evidence and too many convictions based on circumstantial evidence.

The US-based group said France's pre-emptive approach to fighting terrorism and a lack of safeguards within the justice system had put it "on the wrong side of human rights law".

French officials' interrogation tactics, the use of foreign intelligence and suspects' limited access to legal counsel deepen the problem, said the report. 

"French counterterrorism laws and procedures undermine the right of those facing charges of terrorism to a fair trial," the 84-page report released on Wednesday added.

French defence

HRW said a blanket charge often brought against terrorism suspects is at the heart of the problem.

The charge, criminal association in relation to a terrorist undertaking, is too sweeping, the report says, because "no specific terrorist act need be planned, much less executed, to give rise to the offense".

The human rights group also attacked cases brought under the charge "guilty-by-association prosecutions".

It complained that people who had any contact with the suspects - including family members, neighbours and even mere acquaintances - were sometimes detained.

Judith Sunderland, the report's author, said: "It allows for too much flexibility in the interpretation.

"So you have a history in France of using this charge to arrest large numbers of people on the basis of very little evidence they have anything to do with a terrorist plot."

French officials were quick to defend their system.

Luc Chatel, a government spokesman, said: "All our laws on counterterrorism were taken in response to a threat."

Guillaume Didier, a justice ministry spokesman, said: "French justice is exemplary and its counterterrorism laws are regarded as models by other countries around the world."

Psychological pressure

In the 1980s, France was hit by a series of attacks on trains, underground services and department stores.

In 1995, a blast by an Algerian group in Paris' Saint-Michel train station killed eight people and injured 150.

There have been no attacks since, despite calls by an Algeria-based al-Qaeda affiliate to target France.

Sunderland also criticised the French practice of holding suspects for up to six days with little legal counsel.

The report said that there were "credible allegations of physical abuse of terrorism suspects in French police custody," citing testimony from those detained that sleep deprivation, disorientation, constant repetitive questioning and psychological pressure were common.

Sunderland also said that statements provided by third countries, often with poor human rights records, are used in the French proceedings.

"France has an obligation under international law to ensure that any evidence obtained under torture is never used in any part of legal proceedings in France," she said.

The group recommended that France require proof that suspects intend to participate in a terrorist plot and allow for the presence of a lawyer from the beginning of detentions.

Topics in this article
Featured on Al Jazeera
Indonesia's digerati could be crucial to success in the country's upcoming presidential election.
How Brazil's football legend turned every Corinthians' match into a political meeting for democracy.
As the Pakistani army battles Taliban forces, civilians in North Waziristan face an arduous escape for relative safety.
Nepalese trade in a libido-boosting fungus is booming but experts warn over-exploitation could destroy ecosystem.
Muslims and Arabs in the US say they face discrimination in many areas of life, 13 years after the 9/11 attacks.
At one UN site alone, approximately four children below the age of five are dying each day.
Israel's Operation Protective Edge is the third major offensive on the Gaza Strip in six years.
Consumption of traditional nutritional staples such as salmon, moose and bear has fallen in recent generations.
Palestinian families fear Israel's night-time air strikes, as the civilian death toll soars in the Gaza Strip.
join our mailing list