Central & South Asia
Indian PM defended over scam
Attorney general appears in supreme court to answer questions over Manmohan Singh's handling of telecoms scandal.
Last Modified: 23 Nov 2010 20:11 GMT
India, the world's fastest growing mobile phone market, has attracted many investors in recent years [GALLO/GETTY] 

India's attorney general appeared before the supreme court Tuesday to defend Manmohan Singh, the prime minister, against allegations he failed to act over an alleged multi-billion dollar telecoms scam.

The court asked for an explanation why Singh took 16 months to examine a request for his now-sacked telecoms minister to face prosecution over alleged corruption. 

Andimuthu Raja, the telecoms minister, was forced to resign last week after his ministry was accused of selling licences too cheaply in 2007-2008, possibly costing the state $39bn in revenue, according to an official watchdog audit. He denies any wrongdoing.

G.E. Vahanvati, the attorney general, told the judges on Tuesday that Singh "had made all efforts to deal with the complaint".

He told the court that a complaint lodged by Subramanian Swamy, a senior opposition politician, against Raja was "misconceived in law".

Swamy wrote to the prime minister in 2008 demanding that Raja was investigated and prosecuted, but Swamy said he received a reply only in March this year saying no inquiry would be launched.

Flawed process

Singh has not been accused of benefitting from any alleged corruption, but under Indian law the prime minister must approve criminal proceedings against any cabinet member.

Any significant criticism of Singh by the judges could make it hard  for the prime minister to remain in office.

In 2008, India issued 122 new telecoms licences at a price set in 2001.

The state auditor said that the flawed allocation process benefitted selected companies as the telecoms ministry did not carry out the required due diligence and granted 85 out of the 122 licences to ineligible applicants.

He further said that several Indian companies deliberately witheld information, submitted fake documents and used fraudulent measures to get licences.

It is still too early to know if any of the licences would be cancelled or not. There is likely to be pressure not to cancel any licences as operators have invested in networks and these networks have subscribers.

But the government could ask operators to compensate for the potential revenue loss by imposing fines.

Any penalty or adverse regulatory action could affect companies such as Telenor and Etisalat, which were not part of their respective Indian ventures when the licences were distributed.

Vodafone frustrated

India's mobile phone market is the world's fastest-growing with nearly 700 million users, making it a must-invest market for any major global operator.

But regulatory uncertainties have been a concern to operators and and this latest controversy would force future investors to be more careful before they decide to invest in the market.

Vodafone, the single-biggest foreign investor in India, is fighting a $2.5bn tax bill over its acquisition of a mobile firm in the country and has signalled frustration with Indian regulations.

Opposition parties have demanded a thorough parliamentary investigation and have blocked proceedings until the government relents.

The running of government is not affected by the closure of parliament.

Mumbai's financial markets have not been affected by the scandal. But analysts say telecoms stocks would remain vulnerable until there is clarity on whether licences will be revoked or not.

Topics in this article
Featured on Al Jazeera
As Western stars re-release 1980s charity hit, many Africans say it's a demeaning relic that can do more harm than good.
At least 25 tax collectors have been killed since 2012 in Mogadishu, a city awash in weapons and abject poverty.
Tokyo government claims its homeless population has hit a record low, but analysts - and the homeless - beg to differ.
3D printers can cheaply construct homes and could soon be deployed to help victims of catastrophe rebuild their lives.
Pro-Russia leaders' election in Ukraine's east shows bloody conflict is far from a peaceful resolution.
Critics challenge Canberra's move to refuse visas for West Africans in Ebola-besieged countries.
A key issue for Hispanics is the estimated 11.3 million immigrants in the US without papers who face deportation.
In 1970, only two mosques existed in the country, but now more than 200 offer sanctuary to Japan's Muslims.
Hundreds of the country's reporters eke out a living by finding news - then burying it for a price.