Study says Afghan graft worsening

Survey finds Afghans paid nearly $1bn in bribes last year to avail government services.

by
    Hamid Karzai, the Afghan president, has promised to reduce corruption in his government [EPA]

    Yama Torabi, the co-director of IWA, said more than half of Afghans who paid bribes did so at least twice last year. And he said the numbers masked the real depth of the problem, because some of the Afghans surveyed did not use government services in 2009.

    "Not every household is asking for government services in one year," Torabi said in an interview from Kabul. "For example, corruption in land sales only touches 15 per cent of households... but what is the likelihood that a household will sell land in a given year?"

    Police, courts most corrupt

    Corruption appears to be worst amongst Afghanistan's justice and security agencies, according to the survey. Ten per cent of Afghans reported paying bribes to obtain court decisions or police protection. Many of those bribes were expensive and nearly half of them cost more than 2,500 afghanis ($55).

    "When you go to the judiciary, there is a much higher likelihood you will pay a bribe, than, say, when you go to the education department," Torabi said.

    Thirty-eight per cent of Afghans said they were personally affected by police corruption [AFP]

    Forty-two per cent of respondents said the interior ministry was the most corrupt in Afghanistan, followed by the justice ministry at 32 per cent.

    Those findings will be a particular concern to US and Nato commanders in Afghanistan, who are trying to strengthen the police and courts to provide security against the insurgency. Fifty per cent of those surveyed said the government’s rampant corruption was actually helping to strengthen the insurgency.

    "When the justice system is corrupt, people have absolutely no recourse," said Candace Rondeaux, a senior analyst with the International Crisis Group in Kabul. "The corruption drives the general population directly into the arms of the insurgency."

    Hamid Karzai, the Afghan president, has promised to reduce corruption in his government. He established an anti-corruption commission in November, and held a conference on the subject in December.

    But Rondeaux called those efforts "largely cosmetic". And Torabi said the anti-corruption drive has focused on social service agencies - education, health care and the like - while ignoring the police and courts.

    Worsening problem

    IWA's findings suggest that corruption has worsened in Afghanistan over the last few years.

    The group conducted a similar survey in 2007, which found the total cost of bribes was $466m - less than half the level it recorded in 2009.

    The new survey also found that Afghans are less tolerant of corruption than they were several years ago.

    "In 2007, when we did our interviews, we found that people were slightly more tolerant towards corruption, because they believed the salaries of civil servants were very low," Torabi said. "But now the salaries have been increased many times. So people associate the corruption with a life of luxury."

    IWA's findings are slightly less stark than those of the United Nations, which released a report on corruption in January. The UN found that Afghans paid $2.5bn in bribes in 2009, and that 59 per cent of Afghans think corruption is the biggest problem facing the country.

    The IWA report urged the Afghan government to create a stronger office of oversight, and to toughen the penalties for corrupt officials. Rondeaux also said foreign governments should threaten to cut back on aid unless corruption is reduced.

    "I think the only thing the government will understand is the loss of its aid," she said. "You can't keep giving money to a crook."

    SOURCE: Al Jazeera


    ABOUT THE AUTHOR



    YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

    Venezuela in default: What next?

    Venezuela in default: What next?

    As the oil-rich country fails to pay its debt, we examine what happens next and what it means for its people.

    The Muslims of South Korea

    The Muslims of South Korea

    The number of Muslims in South Korea is estimated to be around 100,000, including foreigners.

    What is Mohammed bin Salman's next move?

    What is Mohammed bin Salman's next move?

    There are reports Saudi Arabia is demanding money from the senior officials it recently arrested.