Malaysia caning sentence commuted
Muslim woman who says she drank beer given community service after sultan intervenes.
Last Modified: 01 Apr 2010 08:14 GMT
Shariah laws apply to Muslims in all personal matters, while non-Muslims are covered by civil laws [EPA]

A Muslim woman sentenced to be caned for drinking beer in Malaysia has had her punishment commuted in a surprising turnaround.

The case had raised questions about Islamic laws intruding into personal matters in the country.

Kartika Sari Dewi Shukarno, 33, received a letter from the Pahang Islamic department informing her that the state's sultan had decided to spare her the caning, her lawyer said on Thursday.

Had Kartika's punishment been carried out at the time of her sentencing in July, she would have been the first woman to be caned in Malaysia, where about 60 per cent of the 28 million people are Muslims.

Kartika was sentenced to six strokes of the cane and a fine of 5,000 ringgit ($1,400) for drinking beer in December 2007 at a beach resort.

Malaysia follows a dual-track justice system. Shariah laws apply to Muslims in all personal matters; non-Muslims are covered by civil laws, and are free to drink.

Only three states in Malaysia - Pahang, Perlis and Kelantan - impose caning for drinking alcohol. In the other 10 states it is punishable by a fine.

Media uproar

Kartika pleaded guilty and did not appeal her sentence, but the punishment was
halted at the last minute following an uproar in the media and among rights activists.

Adham Jamalullail, Kartika's lawyer, told the Associated Press news agency that "as a substitution for the caning, the sultan has ordered Kartika to perform community service for three weeks".

Sultan Ahmad Shah is the guardian of Islam in Pahang and its titular head. Most of Malaysia's 13 states are ruled by sultans who usually play a ceremonial role in governance but have the power to rule in Islamic matters.

Shukarno Abdul Muttalib, Kartika's father, said she has been told to report to the Islamic department early on Friday.

"We will abide by the order ... Kartika will go on with her life,'' he said.

The sultan's decision followed Kartika's meeting with the Pahang crown prince last month.

Officials had said the caning would be very different to the corporal punishment administered on male criminals under secular civil laws.

Lifelong scars

Drug offenders, kidnappers and others are caned with a thick rattan stick on bare
buttocks that break the skin and leave lifelong scars.

Kartika's punishment under Islamic laws would have been delivered with a thin cane on the back with her clothes on.

However, in the meantime three other Muslim women were caned for having sex out of wedlock, becoming the first Muslim women to be caned in Malaysia.

Their cases did not draw as much attention because the caning was kept a secret until after it was done.

Subsequently, the women themselves appeared before local media and said they deserved the punishment.

Topics in this article
Featured on Al Jazeera
More than one-quarter of Gaza's population has been displaced, causing a humanitarian crisis.
Ministers and MPs caught on camera sleeping through important speeches have sparked criticism that they are not working.
Muslim charities claim discrimination after major UK banks began closing their accounts.
Italy struggles to deal with growing flood of migrants willing to risk their lives to reach the nearest European shores.
Thousands of Houthi supporters have called for the fall of Yemen's government. But what do the Houthis really want?
New ration reductions and movement restrictions have refugees from Myanmar anxious about their future in Thailand.
US lawyers say poor translations of election materials disenfranchise Native voters.
US drones in Pakistan have killed thousands since 2004. How have leaders defended or decried these deadly planes?
Residents count the cost of violence after black American teenager shot dead by white Missouri police officer.
join our mailing list