[QODLink]
Americas
UN body backs flotilla report
Human Rights Council endorses criticisms but does not call for a criminal investigation into raid on Turkish ship.
Last Modified: 29 Sep 2010 20:18 GMT
The inquiry found 'clear evidence to support prosecutions' over the raid on the Mavi Marmara [AFP]

The United Nations Human Rights Council has endorsed a fiercely critical report on Israel's raid on an aid flotilla that tried to reach the Gaza Strip in May, but stopped short of pressing for an international criminal inquiry.

The resolution, which was moved by Pakistan on behalf of the 57-nation Organisation of the Islamic Conference [OIC], was approved on Wednesday with 30 votes in favour and 15 abstentions.

It "endorses the conclusions contained in the report" of an inquiry ordered by the council on the May 31 incident during which nine Turkish nationals were killed after Israeli soldiers stormed the Mavi Marmara.

The inquiry said Israel broke international humanitarian and human rights law in the incident, and found "clear evidence to support prosecutions" for crimes including "wilful killing; torture or inhuman treatment; wilfully causing great suffering or serious injury to body or health."

It also renewed the mandate of a separate investigation team that has been looking into whether Israelis and Palestinians have been properly investigating alleged rights abuses during the Gaza conflict in 2008-2009.

Israeli rejection

However, there was no indication in two separate resolutions tabled at the 47-nation council that Israel's critics were aiming to have it taken soon before the International Criminal Court [ICC] in the Hague. That possibility was raised on Tuesday by a British judge on the UN council-appointed team that investigated the raid.

Israel has rejected the investigation from the beginning, but it is backing a separate inquiry on the incident set up by Ban Ki-moon, the UN secretary-general, as well as conducting its own.

The European Union's abstained in the vote, citing a failure to include reference to the separate UN inquiry.

The United States was the only nation to oppose the resolution. Eileen Donahoe, the US ambassador, said it was because it deemed it unhelpful in light of Arab-Israeli peace talks and that the UN inquiry took primacy.

"We urge that this report not be used for actions that could disrupt the direct Israeli-Palestinian talks now under way or actions that could make it harder," she said.

The US had earlier also criticised the report for being "unbalanced". 

"We are concerned by the report's unbalanced language, tone and conclusions," Donahoe told the Human Rights Council on Monday.

Source:
Agencies
Topics in this article
People
Country
City
Organisation
Featured on Al Jazeera
Murder of Somali draws ire of foreign African nationals over rising xenophobic violence.
We look at the impact of increased sanctions against the Islamic Republic and ask who it really affects.
Tupamaros enforce rough justice in Venezuela's slums to support socialism, but critics say the group are violent thugs.
More than a decade ago the US launched a war against Afghanistan, but was it a justified battle?
Featured
Two years since the start of the uprising, rebels and Assad's forces remain locked in conflict.
Extensive coverage of political unrest that spread from Istanbul to other areas.
Revelations over NSA spying are threatening president's European trip.
Some urbanites are returning to their rural roots to farm the land.
Kuwait's 'Bidoon' have been stripped of rights and treated as second-class citizens.
join our mailing list