[QODLink]
Opinion

When US 'intelligence' becomes an oxymoron or just moronic

An outdated terror list and the latest NSA scandals are bringing US credibility into question.

Last Modified: 31 Oct 2013 08:38
Danny Schechter

News Dissector Danny Schechter edits MediaChannel.org. He is the author of The Crime of Our Time.
Email Article
Print Article
Share article
Send Feedback
The arrest last week of Tokyo Sexwale, a prominent South African, at JFK airport, was due to his name being on a "list" that goes back to the commie-bashing days of Senators Joe McCarthy and Pat McCarran in the 1950's," writes Schechter [AFP]

A former South African minister, businessman and freedom fighter is arrested at a New York airport. Why? He's on a terror watch list and is still banned. Why is that?

On Saturday, the NSA scandal finally triggered a protest in Washington DC. Activists of the left, liberal and libertarian persuasion took to the streets, rallying behind pictures of Edward Snowden whom our government considers a traitor, but many consider a hero.

On Sunday, in mid-afternoon, a prominent black South African businessman was arrested at JFK airport because he was on a list of people banned from entering the United States.

No reason was given for his being on the list, although he is a well-known former government minister in South Africa, a one-time head of the country's most populated province, and, yes, a former member of the underground, anti-apartheid, military wing of the African National Congress, Umkonto we Sizwe (The Spear of the Nation).

His name is Tokyo Sexwale, so named because of his martial arts prowess as a kid. Alongside Nelson Mandela, he spent years behind bars in Robben Island, South Africa’s notorious political prison. At that time, Mandela was the founder of the ANC's rebel army and had been sentenced to life imprisonment.

In 1995, when I was filming a reunion at the prison for a documentary called Prisoners of Hope, Sewale told me that after he had been captured in a fire fight, he had been thrilled to be sent to the prison that housed his Commander in Chief. He also told me how he and other prisoners left their cells at night - in their imaginations - to visit places like far away New York.

Embarassing restriction

Ironically, Mandela was on this very same terror list for years after his release from prison, and even after his election as South Africa's first black President. During that time, he even toured the US and returned to visit The White House. Tokyo has also visited the US several times, most recently as the Housing minister and a corporate executive.

Whatever [Tokyo's] income and controversial recent history - fired from his post, divorced by his wife etc - he shouldn't be jailed because our intelligence operation so clearly lacks intelligence.

Perhaps these ridiculous rules have been tightened in the Obama years.

In Mandela's case, he was removed from the list near the end of his Presidency on July 1, 200,8 after President George W Bush signed into law a bill allowing then Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice the authority to waive travel restrictions on Mandela and other members of the ANC.

It took a bi-partisan measure in Congress to allow the president to remove the embarrassing restriction.

On that occasion, New York Times columnist Nicholas Kristof wrote, “Sometimes government officials become intoxicated by the counter-terrorism portfolio. Indeed, totally inebriated. To put it simply, they go nuts.”

Kristof ridiculed our government's securocrats then, asking of Mandela, “What did we think he would do, strap on a suicide belt?”

Intelligence misfire

Now, five years later, it looks like the guardians of our surveillance state are the ones committing suicide, by turning the US into a global laughing-stock through tapping the phones of millions of people including as many as 35 heads of State, many from counties we consider allies.

It is also the intelligence of our policies that are being questioned, not just the heavy-handed practices of our snoops and spies. There is clear evidence that Washington worked with and armed real terrorists of the al-Qaeda “brand”, in Libya and now in Syria.

The people who run these agencies seem to be making no sense either, as The New Yorker reported in quoting NSA's General Keith Alexander who denied whistle-blower Snowden's charges in these terms:

"It's like when you were younger - well, this is for boys - you know, when you're younger you say, 'I don't want to take a bath.' You say, 'No, I'll never to take a bath.' Why would you want to take a bath, well, you have to take a bath, clean, da da, da. You say, 'But isn't there a better way?' So we had to take baths, right. Or showers."

Huh? Asks Amy Davidson in The New Yorker: 

“So is reading e-mails the bath and metadata collection the shower? And girls are supposedly OK with both? More mysteriously, why is Alexander comparing people who question his agency's work to dirty children? Alexander then went on to say that leakers might have blood on their hands, and, as Politico noted, accused newspapers of 'selling' Snowden's documents.”

Years ago, statements like this belonged in "the theatre of the absurd”; now they are reported as if they are statements to be taken seriously by well-informed government officials.

Credibility problems

No wonder the Obama Administration is having credibility problems. The President himself, recently visited Sewale's former prison and spoke movingly of the ordeal Mandela and his comrades went though.

Now, one of the prison's most prominent “graduates” is having an ordeal here in the US and is back in detention.

Imagine being in Tokyo's exhausted shoes as he gets off a 14-hour flight only to be challenged at the “border” because of his name being on a “list” that goes back to the commie-bashing days of Senators Joe McCarthy and Pat McCarran in the 1950's.

There are some in South Africa who may wish Tokyo was still the militant he once was, and not a billionaire who went over to the other side in the class war. But, whatever his income and controversial recent history - fired from his post, divorced by his wife etc - he shouldn't be jailed because our intelligence operation so clearly lacks intelligence.

As Reuters reported, “The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, which runs the airport, did not immediately respond to a request for a comment.”

What can they say?

Danny Schechter is the author of the forthcoming Madiba A to Z: The Many Faces of Nelson Mandela. He blogs at Newsdissector.net and edits mediachannel.org.

Follow him on Twitter: @Danny Schechter 

1347

The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera's editorial policy.

Source:
Al Jazeera
Email Article
Print Article
Share article
Send Feedback
Topics in this article
People
Country
City
Organisation
Featured on Al Jazeera
Italy struggles to deal with growing flood of migrants willing to risk their lives to reach the nearest European shores.
Israel's Operation Protective Edge is the third major offensive on the Gaza Strip in six years.
Muslims and Arabs in the US say they face discrimination in many areas of life, 13 years after the 9/11 attacks.
At one UN site alone, approximately four children below the age of five are dying each day.
Featured
< >