[QODLink]
Jagdish Bhagwati
Jagdish Bhagwati
Jagdish Bhagwati is university professor of economics and law at Columbia University.
RSS
The brain-drain panic returns
The outflow of skilled people from Africa to developed countries is worrying, but are there opportunities within Africa?
Last Modified: 03 Feb 2012 14:05
Preventing skilled people emigrating from Africa will not solve the problem, there need to be opportunites for those skilled and highly skilled people within their own countries [GALLO/GETTY]

New York, NY - While developed countries are angst-ridden over mostly illegal immigration by unskilled workers from developing countries, a different set of concerns has surfaced in Africa, in particular, over the legal outflow of skilled, and even more importantly, highly skilled, people to developed countries. This outflow is supposedly a new and damaging "brain drain", with rich countries actively luring away needed skills from poor countries.

This fear is misplaced. At the outset, we have to distinguish between "need" and "demand". Yes, many African countries need skills. But they are unable to absorb them, owing to several factors associated with economic "backwardness".

In India in the 1950s and 1960s - a time when many professionals were emigrating - working conditions were deplorable. Bureaucrats decided whether we could go abroad for conferences. Heads of departments carried inordinate power. So, no surprise, many of us left. We Hindus may believe in an infinity of lifetimes, but we maximise our welfare in this one, just like everyone else.

Besides, simply holding people back, even if feasible, would do little for their countries. The "brain" is not a static concept. Trapped in Kinshasa, under appalling conditions, the brain will drain away in less time than it takes to get to New York.

Moreover, keeping people at home is easier said than done. In many poor countries, except those such as India and South Korea - which have now developed superb educational institutions - the brightest citizens receive their education abroad. The challenge, then, is to prevent them from staying there and settling down.

But, in any event, emigration restrictions today would violate a human right enshrined in current international treaties. But would immigration restrictions work instead, as proposed by some developed-country organisations, which worry about the "brain drain"?

Here, human-rights concerns pose serious difficulties. Could we really say to a Ghanaian doctor that they must return to their country while an immigrant Russian doctor is allowed to settle down and start a new life? This is likely to run afoul of anti-discrimination principles and constitutional provisions in countries such as the United States.

Adopting a 'diaspora' model

The proper response to the outflow of skilled manpower from poor countries, especially those in Africa, is to be found in a different direction. Given that outflows of skilled workers cannot be restricted - and, indeed, should not be - we must devise institutional mechanisms to work with it. This means adopting a "diaspora" model, which implies four policy proposals.

First, stop crying over the fact that the diaspora is not returning home. Instead, nurture the loyalty of professionals settling abroad, so that they assist their home countries in a variety of ways. Thus, they may be offered voting rights. Restrictions on investment and land purchases can be dropped. And immigration experts such as myself have proposed, since the 1970s, that schemes be developed to enable the academic diaspora to run workshops aimed at bringing teachers up to the best international standards.

Second, while the diaspora should be integrated through more rights, its members also ought to accept obligations that put them on an equal footing with those who remain behind. I suggested in the 1970s that a tax be levied on citizens abroad. Known as the "Bhagwati Tax", it is of course "the American way": US citizens and permanent residents abroad, such as those at home, must pay federal taxes.

Third, because skills are necessary for nearly all activities in most of Africa, here and now, we need to organise ways to supply such skills to these countries. I have long argued that, because many in rich countries are retiring while still in sound health, and because altruism increases with age, we could organise a Grey Peace Corps of senior citizens to share their skills in countries whose own trained professionals prefer to settle abroad.

Finally, foreign aid should be used to massively expand training for Africans in all the essential fields in rich countries such as the US, the United Kingdom, France and the Netherlands. They would add to the diaspora, while the Grey Peace Corps would help to fill current needs. When development had taken off, and conditions have improved sufficiently to attract people back to their homelands, the hugely increased diaspora would indeed return, as they have done in India, South Korea and China.

Together, these policies would benefit Africa both immediately and in the long run. Sentimental handwringing over the "brain drain", and foolish attempts at restricting people's mobility, will not.

Jagdish Bhagwati, Professor of Economics and Law at Columbia University and Senior Fellow in International Economics at the Council on Foreign Relations, recently edited, with Gordon Hanson, Skilled Migration Today.

A version of this article was first published on Project Syndicate.

The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera's editorial policy.

Source:
Al Jazeera
Topics in this article
People
Country
City
Organisation
Featured on Al Jazeera
Your chance to be an investigative journalist in Al Jazeera’s new interactive game.
An innovative rehabilitation programme offers Danish fighters in Syria an escape route and help without prosecution.
Street tension between radical Muslims and Holland's hard right rises, as Islamic State anxiety grows.
Take an immersive look at the challenges facing the war-torn country as US troops begin their withdrawal.
Featured
Led by students concerned for their future with 'nothing to lose', it remains to be seen who will blink first.
Taipei has sided with Hong Kong's pro-democracy protesters as relations with Beijing continue downward spiral.
Some say they've 'lost everything' after a toxic spill in August, which was followed by leaks caused by heavy rain.
Many orphanages ignore government orders or operate under the radar, and there are only four inspectors nationwide.
Palestinian citizens of Israel are blocked from living in Jewish communities for lacking 'Zionist vision'.