David C. Swinney
David C. Swinney
David C. Swinney is Principal at the Institute for Rare and Neglected Diseases Drug Discovery.
Old methods for new drugs
Expenditures have increased and not the number of new medicines resulting from human-genome sequencing, says the author.
Last Modified: 08 Dec 2011 09:08
The molecular revolution made the discovery and development of drugs a more rational process [GALLO/GETTY]

Palo Alto, California - Despite high expectations, productivity is frustratingly low in biopharmaceutical research and development. Although expenditures have increased, the number of new medicines resulting from human-genome sequencing has not. This means that a broad variety of diseases are not being treated effectively, in the developed or the developing worlds.

Advances in molecular sciences, corresponding to the sequencing of the human genome in the 1980s, led to the identification of all the human proteins - large, complex molecules necessary for many of the body's functions. Understanding the proteins' roles then led to greater knowledge of the underlying causes of diseases. For example, mutations or defects, at specific molecular locations in human DNA were found to be responsible for some cancers, raising the hope of developing successful therapies tailored to individual patients.

Scientists believed that the ability to visualise and understand human biology at a more detailed level would lead to many new medicines. Identifying the defective molecular parts, known as the drug targets, should have made addressing the causes of disease easier, and would revolutionise the pharmaceutical sciences. And so it has - but without increasing the number of new medicines.

Prior to this molecular revolution, scientists discovered medicines by randomly evaluating different chemicals against phenotypes - an organism's observable characteristics - in authentic biological systems, such as animals or cells. But, unfortunately, the phenotypic strategy is neither efficient nor intellectually satisfying.

The molecular revolution heralded an era in which drug discovery and development would be rational, not random. Contrary to expectations, however, the increased efficiency implied by target identification has not increased productivity. Efforts to address the problem have focussed on how the target was selected, the candidate drugs' efficacy in humans, the risk of undesirable side effects and the efficiency of the discovery process - all to little or no avail.

The July issue of Nature Reviews Drug Discovery analysed how first-in-class medicines - those drugs that successfully established a new class of medicines - were discovered. Despite the emphasis on target-based drug discovery, phenotypic screening produced the lion's share of the first-in-class small-molecule medicines approved between 1999 and 2008 - 28 phenotypic medicines versus 17 target-based drugs. Considering how strongly biased the industry has been towards target-based drug discovery, that imbalance is highly significant.

The Nature Reviews article proposed that lower productivity partly reflects target-based discovery's lack of consideration of the molecular complexities of how the drugs work. Knowing the parts of an efficient machine - a watch, an automobile or a computer - is not enough to describe how it works. The parts must collaborate in precise ways to provide accurate time, reliable transportation or processed information.

Biology is infinitely more complex. The phrase "molecular mechanism of action" (MMOA) describes the way that biological parts collaborate to provide an effective and safe medicine. Addressing the MMOA would contribute to reversing the low productivity of target-based discoveries, because merely knowing the identity of a part involved in a defect may not be sufficient to repair a malfunctioning machine.

The target-based approach is analogous to looking for one's keys in the dark: If they are under a streetlight, they'll be easy to find. Many hoped that the molecular revolution would amount to more streetlights for drug discovery. Unfortunately, it appears that this new light, in most cases, is too dim to illuminate the molecular details of the dynamic human biological machine with sufficient specificity to rationalise the design of new medicines.

The random phenotypic process, though less efficient, will ultimately identify medicines that are effective and work to repair disease. The target-based approach, on the other hand, creates only the illusion of greater efficiency; in reality, its promise has been undermined by its inattention to the MMOA.

There are too many molecular possibilities in dynamic human biology to identify a priori the optimal mechanism of molecular intervention. The way forward is to find a method that combines the efficiency of target-based approaches with the authenticity of phenotypic research. 

David C. Swinney is at the Institute for Rare and Neglected Diseases Drug Discovery and previously was Director of Virology Biochemical Pharmacology at Roche, Palo Alto.

A version of this article was first published on Project Syndicate.

The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not necessarily represent Al Jazeera's editorial policy.

Project Syndicate
Topics in this article
Featured on Al Jazeera
Muslim volunteers face questioning and threat of arrest, while aid has been disrupted or blocked, charities say.
Six months on, outrage and sorrow over the mass schoolgirl abduction has disappeared - except for families in Nigeria.
ISIL combatants seeking an 'exit strategy' from Mideast conflict need positive reinforcement back home, analysts say.
European nation hit by a wave of Islamophobia as many young fighters join ISIL in Syria and Iraq.
Lack of child protection laws means abandoned and orphaned kids rely heavily on the care of strangers.
At least 25 tax collectors have been killed since 2012 in Mogadishu, a city awash in weapons and abject poverty.
Since she was 16-years-old, Scottish Nationalist Party's Sturgeon has strove for independence from the UK.
Armed group's ransom success with German hostages marks a re-emergence, as authorities investigate ISIL links.
Western nations are moving into the resource-rich country after decades of disinterest, challenging China's interests.