[QODLink]
Henry I. Miller
Henry I. Miller
Henry I Miller, a physician and molecular biologist and a fellow at Stanford University's Hoover Institution.
Tropics of cancer?
To treat cancer in the developing world, different techniques are needed than are used in wealthier countries.
Last Modified: 10 Aug 2011 10:52
Thirty countries do not own a single radiotherapy machine - but in poorer countries, cancer could best be treated by preventive measures such as attacking infectious diseases and reducing pollution [EPA]

Cancer is sometimes thought of as a disease of wealthier countries, but it is a major cause of morbidity and mortality in poorer ones as well. Indeed, by the end of this decade, about 150 million people worldwide will have cancer, with approximately 60 per cent of them residing in developing countries.

Although fewer people in developing countries live to the age at which cancer is most prevalent, inadequate nutrition and environmental exposures to viruses and toxins, combined with a paucity of diagnostic and treatment options, increase cancer's incidence and lethality. Many people in poor countries die from cancers that are preventable or treatable in wealthier societies, but they often succumb to other scourges as well, such as infectious diseases. So what could and should be done about this conundrum?

Margaret Chan, the head of the World Health Organisation, and Yukiya Amano, director of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), noted in a recent article that most developing countries' health-care systems are designed to cope with infectious diseases rather than cancer. I find this to be a rational strategy, given the heavy toll that infections take, and that many can be prevented and treated at a relatively modest cost.

The diagnosis and treatment of most types of cancer in developing countries would require a huge and daunting investment in infrastructure. As Chan and Amano point out:

"[M]ost lack the funds, equipment, and qualified personnel needed to provide basic care for cancer patients. Thirty countries - half of them in Africa - do not have a single radiotherapy machine. And these countries certainly do not have the financial resources, facilities, equipment, technology, infrastructure, staff, or training to cope with the long-term demands of cancer care."

In order to begin addressing these deficiencies, "the IAEA's work involves building countries' capacity for radiation medicine. But technology means nothing without well-trained and motivated staff to use it".

Such an approach is, however, poorly focused and unlikely to be cost-effective. As the United Nations' own data make clear, infectious diseases, many of them preventable and treatable, remain the scourge of poorer populations. In 2008, about 250 million cases of malaria caused almost a million deaths, mostly of children under five. In virtually all poor, malaria-endemic countries, there is inadequate access to antimalarial medicines (especially artemisinin-based combination therapy).

The incidence of malaria could be reduced drastically by the judicious application of the mosquito-killing chemical DDT, but UN and national regulators have curtailed its availability, owing to misguided notions about its toxicity. Hundreds of millions suffer from other neglected tropical diseases, including lymphatic filariasis and cholera.

Although new HIV infections worldwide declined slightly during the past decade, 2.7 million people contracted the virus in 2008, and there were 2m HIV/AIDS-related deaths. By the end of that year, more than 4 million people in low- and middle-income countries were receiving anti-retroviral therapy, but more than 5 million who were HIV-positive remained untreated. The number of new cases of tuberculosis cases worldwide is increasing, and the growing emergence of multidrug-resistant strains of the bacteria is especially worrisome.

According to UN statistics, about 15 per cent of the world's population lacks access to safe drinking water, and "in 2008, 2.6bn people had no access to a hygienic toilet or latrine", while "1.1bn were defecating in the open". Primitive approaches to managing sewage continue to spread infections such as schistosomiasis, trachoma, viral hepatitis, and cholera.

Many cancers are likely caused by chronic viral infections, another reason that it is surely more sensible to attack infectious diseases by improving access to clean water, basic sanitation, antibiotics, and vaccines than it is to build radiotherapy facilities. In some technology-poor but oil-rich Middle East countries, state-of-the-art radiotherapy (and cardio-pulmonary bypass) equipment has been delivered, but never used, or has been damaged by electrical surges or power outages. And many poor countries do not have a single medical school, and when their citizens study abroad, they often stay there, or are ill-equipped for a low-tech milieu that is so different from where they trained.

Although the use of big-ticket equipment, expensive chemotherapy drugs, and sophisticated and complex procedures such as bone marrow transplantation would not be wise, this is not to say that we should give up entirely on cancer treatment in developing countries. Sometimes, prevention, diagnosis, and treatment are cost-effective. Vaccines to prevent hepatitis A and B (and C, when one becomes available) reduce the incidence not only of the viral infections, but also of sequelae such as cirrhosis and hepatic carcinoma. And public-health efforts to curb air pollution and smoking could reduce the prevalence of lung cancer in Asia and Africa.

Another example is cervical cancers, many of which can be prevented by vaccines against human papilloma virus. And acetic acid can be used to visualise cervical cancers, which can then be treated with cryotherapy (freezing).

The bottom line is that, in a world of limited health-care resources, we need to make hard decisions that will deliver high-impact outcomes for the most people at the least cost.

Henry I Miller, a physician and molecular biologist and a fellow at Stanford University's Hoover Institution, was the founding director of the Office of Biotechnology at the US Food & and Drug Administration. His most recent book is The Frankenfood Myth.

A version of this article was first published by Project Syndicate.

The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not necessarily represent Al Jazeera's editorial policy.

 

Source:
Al Jazeera
Topics in this article
People
Organisation
Featured on Al Jazeera
More than one-quarter of Gaza's population has been displaced, causing a humanitarian crisis.
Ministers and MPs caught on camera sleeping through important speeches have sparked criticism that they are not working.
Muslim charities claim discrimination after major UK banks began closing their accounts.
Italy struggles to deal with growing flood of migrants willing to risk their lives to reach the nearest European shores.
Featured
The seizure of the Tabqa airbase highlights the Islamic State's consolidation of power in eastern Syria, analysts say.
Traditional spring festival blossoms outside India through fun runs, raves and TV commercials.
Parents unable to look after children are marrying them off at a tender age, exposing them to maternal deaths.
New measures needed as dozens of citizens fighting with Islamic State pose home-grown terror threat, PM Abbott says.
Israel has re-arrested dozens of Palestinians in the West Bank, an act a human rights group says is 'unjustified'.
join our mailing list