Analysis: Repeating history?

The Petraeus testimony underlines the similarities between Iraq and Vietnam.

    William Westmoreland gave congress
    an optimistic view from Vietnam [AP]

    In an address to the joint houses of congress in 1967, General Westmoreland said that US forces would win and that there was "light at the end of the tunnel".

    He claimed the enemy (the Viet Cong and North Vietnamese Army) were a defeated force and could no longer mount a credible offence on the battlefield.
     
    'War of attrition'

    It was the first time a battle commander had addressed congress during a war, and to thunderous applause he proclaimed: "We will prevail in Vietnam over the communist aggressor."
     
    In other meetings Westmoreland said: "We have found it to be like no other war that we have fought before ... there are no moving front lines, just a changing picture of small actions scattered over the whole country."

    Special report

    But he remained optimistic, saying his troops had "learned to work alongside the Vietnamese army while encouraging the development of a representative government".

    He later said they were "winning a war of attrition", forecast that "mopping up the enemy" would take around two years and that the war had reached a stage "where the end comes into view".

    All of these messages were politically crafted, designed to gain support for the war in the minds of the American people, although in his case, he was relating a genuine improvement in American fortunes.
     
    'Shock and awe'

    Which made the shock of the Tet offensive in January 1968 all the greater as more than 100 cities were attacked, including assaults on General Westmoreland's headquarters and the US embassy in Saigon, which was occupied for a few hours.

    A few months later he was asking for more troops, the US continued to suffer heavy casualties until a ceasefire was negotiated in 1973.

    General Petraeus is delivering a similar message, saying the so-called "surge" has helped improve security in Baghdad and reduced fighting in al-Anbar province, and that American troops are integrating into neighbourhoods instead of patrolling in armoured vehicles.

    While he concedes there has been less political progress during the surge, he remains optimistic and argues Iraq's political leaders should be given more time and that the US should "stay the course".

    Calls to stay the course in Iraq are "the same kind of thinking, actually, that got us mired in Vietnam," said John Kerry, the Democrat senator on ABC television, adding that the mission was "disastrous".

    What remains to be seen is whether General Petraeus will suffer the same fate as his predecessor.

    Libel action

    After the shock counter-attack of the Tet offensive, Johnson limited further increases in troops, while Westmoreland himself was promoted to US army chief of staff, but as his request for 200,000 more troops had been rejected his position effectively became untenable and he retired in 1972.

    The general later said: "It's not that we lost the war militarily. The fact is that we as a nation did not make good our commitment to the South Vietnamese."

    Ten years later he brought a $120m lawsuit against CBS television over a documentary which implied he had deceived President Johnson - and by definition, the American public - about the strength of the enemy troops in Vietnam.

    After a four-month-long hearing, the case was settled just as it was due to go to the jury and Westmoreland accepted an apology from the broadcaster.

    "I have no apologies, no regrets. I've been hung in effigy. I've been spat upon. You just have to let those things bounce off," he told AP news agency in 1985.

    General Westmoreland died in 2005, aged 91.

    SOURCE: Al Jazeera and agencies


    YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

    Double standards: 'Why aren't we all with Somalia?'

    Double standards: 'Why aren't we all with Somalia?'

    More than 300 people died in Somalia but some are asking why there was less news coverage and sympathy on social media.

    How Moscow lost Riyadh in 1938

    How Moscow lost Riyadh in 1938

    Russian-Saudi relations could be very different today, if Stalin hadn't killed the Soviet ambassador to Saudi Arabia.

    Kobe Steel: A scandal made in Japan

    Kobe Steel: A scandal made in Japan

    Japan's third-largest steelmaker has admitted it faked data on parts used in cars, planes and trains.