[QODLink]
Archive
The ugly face of Israeli checkpoints

There is a bottleneck of people at the small entrance to Endless Checkpoints, a recently opened photography exhibition in Tel Aviv.

Last Modified: 08 Mar 2006 03:59 GMT
A Palestinian has to show the contents of his bag

There is a bottleneck of people at the small entrance to Endless Checkpoints, a recently opened photography exhibition in Tel Aviv.

To get into the main exhibition hall, where pictures of daily strife at a series of West Bank checkpoints are exhibited, visitors must first pass a TV screen showing footage of the Qalandiya checkpoint.

And here is where they stop. 

Hundreds of Palestinians are depicted waiting to reach the inspection point, squashed, flanked by wire fences. The camera pauses on a young mother on the edge of tears as she tries to comfort a screaming toddler.

Like the photographs on display inside, this is not an uncommon image. But it is one that it is rarely seen inside Israel.

One visitor from Holon, south of Tel Aviv, as she leaves the hall past the same video loop, says: "This exhibition shows a horrible and disgusting situation.

"It's absurd that this has gone on for so long and impossible that it will stay this way."

Endless Checkpoints, at the College of Geographic Photography in the southern suburbs of Tel Aviv, was put together by Machsom Watch, an Israeli activist group.

Since 2001, this organisation of about 400 women against the occupation has maintained a daily presence at checkpoints, to protest, to witness, to monitor and in some cases to exert a restraining effect on the Israeli soldiers on duty.

Documenting checkpoints

Esti Tsal, one of the exhibition curators, says: "We stand there every day, twice daily, to protest and also to document and to tell others what is not being told."

"As a Jew, this is very strong"

Male exhibition visitor

Inside the main hall, about 80 photographs, taken by the women of Machsom Watch, provide documentation of Palestinian encounters with Israeli soldiers at checkpoints.

There is a full wall display of pictures showing schoolchildren crossing barbed wire, cement blocks and piles of rubbish, or having schoolbags inspected by soldiers.

There is a series of shots of a soldier's pointed finger protruding from a concrete inspection kiosk, gesturing for Palestinians waiting to pass outside to open bags of clothing or plastic bags of pitta bread for inspection.

A male visitor from Jerusalem says: "As a Jew, this is very strong.

"The Jew for 2000 years was at the checkpoint as a refugee, but now he has become the soldier at the checkpoint. So the question is, how do you retain your morality as a sovereign state, that you maintained as a minority?"

Introspection

Simon McDonald, the British ambassador to Israel, attended the exhibition opening last week.

"These pictures do not tell the whole story, and it is important to have that in mind when looking at the photos, but they do tell an important part of the story," he said.

Palestinians are blocked at the
Qalandiya checkpoint

"A sign of a healthy democracy is one that is not afraid to take a hard look at its problems and to deal with them. I think that the women of Machsom Watch help Israel do this."

Since these photographs span a period of four years, they also chart the progress of checkpoints, from barriers in the road to sophisticated terminals - known as "border crossings" - consisting of processing sheds flanked by access turnstyles.

Tsal says: "They are more modernised and more cruel, more inhumane, all pavements and walls and gates and Jeeps. You don't see people any more because they are inside the terminal buildings and we cannot go in and see them, speak with them."

The exhibition's location on the outskirts of Tel Aviv will necessarily limit its audience, but it seems Machsom Watch could not find another home for it.

"For more than a year, we were looking for a space in central Tel Aviv that everybody could reach," says Tsal. "We got a big 'No' from many galleries and commercial spaces we approached."

Media publicity

Endless Checkpoints has received a surprising amount of media publicity - appearing in Israeli newspapers and listings magazines such as Time Out and cropping up on TV news, on daytime programmes and evening culture show slots.

"I am very surprised, as I was sure nobody would care," says Tsal. "But it has been in the media almost every day."

A photograph from the exhibition
taken by Esti Tsal

Still, exhibitors worry that Endless Checkpoints may reach only an already sympathetic audience.

Giora Salmi, manager of the college, says: "It is really popular compared to other exhibitions here.

"But most people who come are already sympathetic to the work of Machsom Watch; they already agree. We want to reach other people, the ones who ordinarily visit galleries because they are fond of art."

Some visitors found the exhibition limited in its power to properly convey reality.

A visitor from Tel Aviv said: "It can't do the situation justice because these are just pictures. You can't smell a picture, have the feeling of fear, the feeling of oppression in a picture - it can't be the same as seeing it in real life."

Opinions

Another female visitor agreed: "I find the exhibition extraordinary, but the pictures are too beautiful and a bit glossed over, while the reality is very depressing and very bad."

A few visitors are angered by the "unbalanced" nature of the exhibition. "Some of my students were upset that the photographs do not explain what the soldier in the frame is feeling," says Salmi.

There are a few unfavourable comments in the exhibition visitor's guest book too, say the curators, describing Machsom Watch as "stupid women" who "don't understand".

But for those Israelis who are unable to visit these checkpoints, because they cannot or are too afraid, these photographs are the next best thing.

Tsal says: "We are trying to have Israeli society look in the mirror and say, 'We cannot go on like this, controlling two million people. Our face has become very ugly.'"

Source:
Aljazeera
Topics in this article
People
Country
City
Featured on Al Jazeera
An innovative rehabilitation programme offers Danish fighters in Syria an escape route and help without prosecution.
Street tension between radical Muslims and Holland's hard right rises, as Islamic State anxiety grows.
Take an immersive look at the challenges facing the war-torn country as US troops begin their withdrawal.
Ministers and MPs caught on camera sleeping through important speeches have sparked criticism that they are not working.
Featured
Chinese scientists are designing a particle-smashing collider so massive it could encircle a city.
Critics say the government is going full-steam ahead on economic recovery at the expense of human rights.
Spirits are high in Scotland's 'Whisky Capital of the World' with one distillery thirsty for independence.
President Poroshenko arrives in Washington on Thursday with money and military aid on his mind, analysts say.
Early players in private medicine often focused on volume over quality, turning many Chinese off for-profit care.
join our mailing list