US: White phosphorus use legitimate

The top US general has defended the use of white phosphorus munitions in combat against Iraqi fighters as a legitimate tool of the military.

Last Modified: 29 Nov 2005 23:27 GMT
White phosphorus munitions shower skin-burning particles

The top US general has defended the use of white phosphorus munitions in combat against Iraqi fighters as a legitimate tool of the military.

Allegations that civilians were victims of white phosphorus bombs in the Falluja battle last year has put the spotlight on a weapon that showers down incendiary particles that burn right through skin.

"A bullet goes through skin even faster than white phosphorus does," General Peter Pace, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said at a Pentagon press conference in Washington on Tuesday.

"So I would rather have the proper instrument applied at the proper time, as precisely as possible, to get the job done, in a way that kills as many of the bad guys as possible and does as little collateral damage as possible."

He said no military went to greater lengths to avoid civilian casualties than the US military.

Smoke screens

Pace said white phosphorus was mainly used to mark targets for air strikes, and to create smoke screens for moving forces around a battlefield unseen.

"White phosphorus is a legitimate tool of the military," he said.

"It is not a chemical weapon. It is an incendiary. And it is well within the law of war to use those weapons as they're being used, for marking and for screening," Pace said.

An account of the battle for Falluja published in a US army journal in April said white phosphorus was also used to flush fighters out of trench lines in what were described as "shake and bake" missions.

Odd encounter

In an unusual exchange, Pace said American troops in Iraq had a duty to intercede and stop abuse of prisoners by Iraqi security personnel, but Defence Secretary Donald Rumsfeld contradicted him, saying he believed the general meant to say the US soldiers had to report the abuse, not stop it.

Rumsfeld: Inhumane behaviour
is worrisome and harmful

Pace, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, stood firm. "If they are physically present when inhumane treatment is taking place, sir, they have an obligation to try to stop it," Pace told his civilian boss.

The exchange occurred on Tuesday during a discussion at the Pentagon news conference about the relationship between US forces in Iraq and an Iraqi government considered sovereign by the US.
A questioner asked whether, since the US and its allies train Iraqi forces, the foreigners might be responsible for preventing mistreatment of people under arrest.

"There are a lot of people involved in this, dozens of countries trying to help train these Iraqi forces. Any instance of inhumane behaviour is obviously worrisome and harmful to them when that occurs," Rumsfeld said.

Support needed

"Iraq knows, of certain knowledge, that they need the support of the international community. And a good way to lose it is to make a practice of something that is inconsistent with the values of the international community," the US defence secretary said.
Rumsfeld added: "Now, you know, I can't go any further in talking about it. Obviously, the United States does not have a responsibility when a sovereign country engages in something that they disapprove of."

Top US general Pace (L) joined
issue with Rumsfeld on Tuesday

Pace, the highest-ranking American in uniform, was asked what orders the troops had to handle such incidents. He said: "It is absolutely the responsibility of every US service member if they see inhumane treatment being conducted, to intervene, to stop it."

He said soldiers who hear of but did not see an incident should deal with it through superiors of the offending Iraqis.
That was when Rumsfeld stepped to the microphone and said: "I don't think you mean they have an obligation to physically stop it. It's to report it."
Pace then repeated to Rumsfeld that intervening when witnessing abuse was the order, not reporting it.

Topics in this article
Featured on Al Jazeera
Italy struggles to deal with growing flood of migrants willing to risk their lives to reach the nearest European shores.
Israel's Operation Protective Edge is the third major offensive on the Gaza Strip in six years.
Muslims and Arabs in the US say they face discrimination in many areas of life, 13 years after the 9/11 attacks.
At one UN site alone, approximately four children below the age of five are dying each day.
A political power struggle masquerading as religious strife grips Nigeria - with mixed-faith couples paying the price.
The current surge in undocumented child migrants from Central America has galvanized US anti-immigration groups.
Absenteeism among doctors at government hospitals is rife, prompting innovative efforts to ensure they turn up for work.
Marginalised and jobless, desperate young men in Nairobi slums provide fertile ground for al-Shabab.
The Khmer Rouge tribunal is set to hear genocide charges for targeting ethnic Vietnamese and Cham Muslims.
join our mailing list