[QODLink]
Archive
Dodgy dossier earns Blair rebuke
An influential British parliamentary committee has roundly criticised Tony Blair's government for the manner it prepared its dossier to justify the Iraq war.
Last Modified: 11 Sep 2003 11:00 GMT
The Committee report turns the heat on Blair
An influential British parliamentary committee has roundly criticised Tony Blair's government for the manner it prepared its dossier to justify the Iraq war.

But the Intelligence and Security Committee in a report published on Thursday absolved the government, facing its worst crisis of credibility, of the more serious charge of 'sexing up' its claims to justify the war against Iraq.

The committee is stuffed with ruling Labour party members with an only fair sprinking of opposition members.

The committee found the government claims about Iraq's chemical and biological weapons capacity did not give a ''balanced view".

It said the key point that Iraq could fire banned weapons at just 45 minutes notice lacked context, which was ''unhelpful to an understanding of the issue''.

The disputed 45-minute claim was used by Prime Minister Blair in moulding public opinion in favour of the war.

The claim is also at the very heart of an escalating controversy that has engulfed Blair's government over whether it had hyped the case for a war that most Britons opposed.

"We regard the initial failure by the MoD to disclose that some staff had put their concerns in writing to their line managers as unhelpful and potentially misleading"

British Parliamentary Committee



Hoon Criticised

The committee's sternest criticism was reserved for the Defence Secretary Geoff Hoon for his inability to disclose that some intelligence staff members had reservations about the dossier that the government prepared.

"We regard the initial failure by the MoD to disclose that some staff had put their concerns in writing to their line managers as unhelpful and potentially misleading," the committee said.

"We are disturbed that after the first evidence session…the Defence Secretary decided against giving instructions for a letter to be written to us outlining the concerns," the committee noted.

The rap from the committee is certain to add to Hoon's discomfort, who is already under pressure to quit over the apparent suicide of British weapons' expert, David Kelly.

At the very least, the committee report comes in as a severe embarassment for a discredited government.

Inadequate Intelligence

The committee said British intelligence chiefs did not know for sure what weapons Iraq had produced or in what quanitities.

"This uncertainty should have been highlighted to give a balanced view of Saddam Hussein's chemical and biological capacity," it said.

The report, however, extended small mercies to the embittered government.

It hotly disputed the BBC report that suggested the dossier on Iraqi weapons had been exaggerated to justify the war. 

The committee said the dossier had "not been sexed up" by Alistair Campbell, Blair's close aide.

Source:
Agencies
Topics in this article
People
Country
Organisation
Featured on Al Jazeera
Indonesia's digerati could be crucial to success in the country's upcoming presidential election.
How Brazil's football legend turned every Corinthians' match into a political meeting for democracy.
As the Pakistani army battles Taliban forces, civilians in North Waziristan face an arduous escape for relative safety.
Nepalese trade in a libido-boosting fungus is booming but experts warn over-exploitation could destroy ecosystem.
Featured
Palestinian families fear Israel's night-time air strikes, as the civilian death toll soars in the Gaza Strip.
China still uses labour camps to silence democracy activists and others it considers malcontents.
Myanmar's Karen veterans of WWII, despite being abandoned by the British, recall their service with fondness.
Sri Lanka refugees stranded on a boat near Australia's shoreline are in legal limbo and fear torture if sent home.
The death of Hamed Shehab on Wednesday in an Israeli air strike has triggered fear and anger among journalists in Gaza.
join our mailing list